The Oklahoma Fugitive

Record archive

MOTION OBJECTING TO FURTHER PROCEEDINGS DURING PENDENCY OF DISQUALIFICATION MOTION AND REQUEST FOR IMMEDIATE RULING ON THE PAPERS (FROM PRO-SE DEFENDANT) (COPY PUT IN JUDGE AND DA'S BOX)

Source-owning proceeding: CM-2024-00301 · Existing document identity: DOC-1085057485

Existing contextual aliases: D29. Aliases do not establish provenance.

View original PDF Download unchanged original

Unmodified, unredacted retained PDF; 9 physical page/image position(s), 534053 bytes.

Original and shipped SHA-256 7acc83d02f7934ab87d7b60a5d4bc5e76521126e672ce25e8bd8a5733b252c71

Separate docket appearances

A docket entry is distinct from the source-owned original document. Cross-proceeding entries link to this single original; no second authoritative copy is created.

CM-2024-00301 · ROW-056 · entry date as printed: 05/23/2025

Existing text coverage and recorded date roles

Only the listed existing permitted passages are searchable. Original images/PDFs and existing omissions remain unchanged; no OCR or inferred complete text. Representations remain separate and passages retain their existing source order/locators. No inferred continuous page transcription.

Inherited transcription/review notes describe prior source review, including any wording such as “this session”; no new transcription was performed for this export.

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1jRcFtcraxsmgGwpi7as9kXRy2Y_bwWwe
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1jRcFtcraxsmgGwpi7as9kXRy2Y_bwWwe:substantive-completion:033

Selected existing passages

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1jRcFtcraxsmgGwpi7as9kXRy2Y_bwWwe
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1jRcFtcraxsmgGwpi7as9kXRy2Y_bwWwe:excerpt:paragraph-1

1. Defendant, appearing pro se, respectfully submits this motion objecting to further
proceedings in the above-captioned case while his formal Motion to Disqualify the
Honorable Judge Jared Sigler remains pending.

Exact text SHA-256 1901858995c11a8babaae9f6173a54da5af84fdd92dc4cd24786f4091363f26b

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1jRcFtcraxsmgGwpi7as9kXRy2Y_bwWwe
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1jRcFtcraxsmgGwpi7as9kXRy2Y_bwWwe:excerpt:paragraph-2

2. Pursuant to Rule 15 of the Rules for District Courts of Oklahoma, the disqualification
motion triggered an automatic stay, which precludes any further judicial action until the
motion is overruled of record.

Exact text SHA-256 183297344003b8320236f8eadb5cf5c3aa33985681e0cfb4ca8df61d1a740b26

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1jRcFtcraxsmgGwpi7as9kXRy2Y_bwWwe
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1jRcFtcraxsmgGwpi7as9kXRy2Y_bwWwe:excerpt:paragraph-3

3. Defendant hereby waives any hearing on the disqualification motion before the presiding
judge and requests that the motion be ruled on the papers.

Exact text SHA-256 5dbb9388d0ef444aaf77d1bd4d9f8d3bc750f62b4f01532d07bcf1a86e4416c1

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1jRcFtcraxsmgGwpi7as9kXRy2Y_bwWwe
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1jRcFtcraxsmgGwpi7as9kXRy2Y_bwWwe:excerpt:paragraph-4

4. Defendant further objects to the May 28, 2025 status setting and notifies the Court that he
will not appear before Judge Sigler unless and until the disqualification motion is
overruled of record.

Exact text SHA-256 fa6839e706e11d360b668c5822e17a35aa382c420c510fde5d0eef2fee7343df

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1jRcFtcraxsmgGwpi7as9kXRy2Y_bwWwe
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1jRcFtcraxsmgGwpi7as9kXRy2Y_bwWwe:excerpt:paragraph-5

5. On May 14, 2025, Defendant filed a verified Motion to Disqualify the Honorable Judge
Jared Sigler pursuant to Rule 15 and 20 O.S. § 1401.

Exact text SHA-256 48b65594fd5811aff98f76c332145c7e8fab2ef8223a2567d109b93b75bd30f7

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1jRcFtcraxsmgGwpi7as9kXRy2Y_bwWwe:substantive-completion:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1jRcFtcraxsmgGwpi7as9kXRy2Y_bwWwe:substantive-completion:033:title

MOTION OBJECTING TO FURTHER PROCEEDINGS DURING PENDENCY OF DISQUALIFICATION MOTION AND REQUEST FOR IMMEDIATE RULING ON THE PAPERS
I. PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND

Exact text SHA-256 538b63a0700ac44205cdcc69351214478dc616dffda285468b557d1fa74f0c9e

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1jRcFtcraxsmgGwpi7as9kXRy2Y_bwWwe:substantive-completion:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1jRcFtcraxsmgGwpi7as9kXRy2Y_bwWwe:substantive-completion:033:paragraphs-6-8

6. This filing included a sworn affidavit attesting to facts that, if true, require disqualification or at minimum raise substantial doubts about impartiality.[1]
7. Rule 15(d), effective November 18, 2024, provides in relevant part:
When an interested party has filed a formal motion for a judge to disqualify or recuse, the judge cannot proceed with the case until the disqualification stands overruled of record…[2]
8. Nevertheless, on May 15, 2025, Judge Sigler convened an in-chambers proceeding, attempted to contact Defendant by telephone, and set a future hearing for May 28, 2025, even though the disqualification motion remained pending and unresolved.

Exact text SHA-256 99c5bef90fc3082e4ab2b15ffa9e0380c27fd718a3335fda795ba52eddacd413

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1jRcFtcraxsmgGwpi7as9kXRy2Y_bwWwe:substantive-completion:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1jRcFtcraxsmgGwpi7as9kXRy2Y_bwWwe:substantive-completion:033:paragraphs-9-12

9. The minute entry confirms the Court appeared in chambers and notes the presence of a court reporter, along with a $20 court reporter fee.
10. The minute entry characterizes the future date only as “status on hearing,” referring back to the hearing originally set for May 15; it does not specify any distinct purpose or direct Defendant’s personal appearance.
11. No reference is made to the pending Motion to Disqualify, and no order to appear on May 28 was entered.[3]
12. No written ruling has issued, and the stay remains in full force and effect.

Exact text SHA-256 269f1c96ac668c84583ce48a84a248fce8bb8d2d8c619400da567200f4656d3c

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1jRcFtcraxsmgGwpi7as9kXRy2Y_bwWwe:substantive-completion:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1jRcFtcraxsmgGwpi7as9kXRy2Y_bwWwe:substantive-completion:033:footnotes-1-3

Footnotes to Section I:
[1] Motion to Disqualify and Affidavit, filed May 14, 2025 (on file with the Court Clerk).
[2] Rule 15(d), Rules for District Courts of Oklahoma (eff. Nov. 18, 2024).
[3] Minute Entry dated May 15, 2025 (on file); OCIS Fee Ledger dated May 15, 2025 (showing $20 Court Reporter Fee).

Exact text SHA-256 84b2bdc6ba966f6521e4416af1858775ae46715474d8ddfe34595927984d6f2e

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1jRcFtcraxsmgGwpi7as9kXRy2Y_bwWwe:substantive-completion:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1jRcFtcraxsmgGwpi7as9kXRy2Y_bwWwe:substantive-completion:033:paragraphs-13-14

II. LEGAL AUTHORITY
13. The language of Rule 15(d) is mandatory. Once a disqualification motion is filed, the judge “cannot proceed with the case” until the motion “stands overruled of record.”
14. The rule does not provide exceptions for administrative acts, in-chambers scheduling, or non-adversarial proceedings.

Exact text SHA-256 23b90e0d195bdb88c40065f451e240863fe3453b0491937e2fb00c7ee1f783ce

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1jRcFtcraxsmgGwpi7as9kXRy2Y_bwWwe:substantive-completion:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1jRcFtcraxsmgGwpi7as9kXRy2Y_bwWwe:substantive-completion:033:paragraphs-15-21

15. The moment the motion is filed, jurisdiction to act is suspended until the challenge is resolved in compliance with Rule 15.
16. In Miller Dollarhide, P.C. v. Tal, the Oklahoma Supreme Court held that continued participation by a judge after a disqualification motion has been filed results in a deprivation of due process.
17. Judicial acts undertaken while disqualification is pending are structurally defective and may be set aside on that basis alone.[4]
18. In Clark v. Board of Education, the Court held that even the failure to rule on a disqualification motion constitutes a due process violation because it deprives the movant of access to appellate review.
19. Judges are constitutionally obligated to rule promptly so that recusal disputes can be resolved by higher authority if necessary.[5]
20. Finally, Pierce v. Pierce reaffirms that disqualification is not solely about actual bias—it is also about the appearance of impartiality.
21. The legitimacy of the judicial process depends on public confidence in its fairness.

Exact text SHA-256 a846627e07e2c33c8c723b5e062cf93e93a0d5e3b5400bcd9421d64fa8f74fba

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1jRcFtcraxsmgGwpi7as9kXRy2Y_bwWwe:substantive-completion:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1jRcFtcraxsmgGwpi7as9kXRy2Y_bwWwe:substantive-completion:033:paragraph-22

22. Failure to recuse when reasonable questions exist compromises that legitimacy and constitutes reversible error.[6]

Exact text SHA-256 6fdc5df6914a9eb486b2d22f1b1c106f37a101eef6ffb2b2301235ad4da3719d

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1jRcFtcraxsmgGwpi7as9kXRy2Y_bwWwe:substantive-completion:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1jRcFtcraxsmgGwpi7as9kXRy2Y_bwWwe:substantive-completion:033:footnotes-4-6

Footnotes to Section II:
[4] Miller Dollarhide, P.C. v. Tal, 2007 OK 58, ¶¶ 10–11, 163 P.3d 548.
[5] Clark v. Bd. of Educ., 2001 OK 56, ¶¶ 9–10.
[6] Pierce v. Pierce, 2001 OK 97, ¶¶ 19–22, 39 P.3d 791.

Exact text SHA-256 fd2c4141fc4b2a646e7326e99806bdc928c9411221808bd771f9af55272b8b87

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1jRcFtcraxsmgGwpi7as9kXRy2Y_bwWwe:substantive-completion:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1jRcFtcraxsmgGwpi7as9kXRy2Y_bwWwe:substantive-completion:033:paragraphs-23-26

III. OBJECTION AND REQUEST FOR RULING
23. Defendant hereby formally objects to all judicial action taken by Judge Sigler on or after May 15, 2025, as having occurred during the Rule 15(d) stay and without lawful jurisdiction.
24. This includes the in-chambers proceeding held on that date and the setting of a future status setting for May 28, 2025 at 9:00 a.m.[7]
25. The May 15 minute entry expressly omits any language ordering Defendant to appear on May 28; it states only that the matter is “passed” for a future status on hearing.
26. Under Rule 15(d), no such status setting may compel Defendant’s attendance because the presiding judge lacks jurisdiction to proceed while the disqualification motion is unresolved. Defendant therefore gives notice that he will not appear before Judge Sigler unless and until the disqualification motion is ruled upon and overruled of record.

Exact text SHA-256 7ad7e683ebd6917b7d4a49b78aafe2588000c0a2900e7f08d5af46f42cb9326b

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1jRcFtcraxsmgGwpi7as9kXRy2Y_bwWwe:substantive-completion:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1jRcFtcraxsmgGwpi7as9kXRy2Y_bwWwe:substantive-completion:033:paragraphs-27-31

27. Defendant respectfully requests that the Court vacate the May 28, 2025 setting and refrain from issuing any order requiring appearance until the disqualification matter is ruled upon and overruled of record.[8]
28. This objection is not an act of defiance but a lawful invocation of the due process rights secured by Rule 15 and Oklahoma constitutional law.
29. Defendant hereby waives any right to a hearing before Judge Sigler on the disqualification motion and respectfully requests that the Court issue a ruling on the papers.
30. All other procedural rights under Rule 15 are expressly reserved.
31. Defendant further reserves all available appellate and supervisory remedies under Oklahoma law, including writs of prohibition or mandamus, as appropriate depending on the Court’s handling of the disqualification motion.[9]

Exact text SHA-256 1c2e50f11c249e8322f36675de94123a56a82ad6598abc99cadff860eb0d7d5a

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1jRcFtcraxsmgGwpi7as9kXRy2Y_bwWwe:substantive-completion:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1jRcFtcraxsmgGwpi7as9kXRy2Y_bwWwe:substantive-completion:033:footnotes-7-9

Footnotes to Section III:
[7] Miller Dollarhide, supra note 4.
[8] Rule 15(d), supra note 2; Minute Entry dated May 15, 2025 (status set without appearance order).
[9] Rule 15(b), Rules for District Courts of Oklahoma

Exact text SHA-256 6fd5cdd9166ada6ebd3edc461a7d2d4aa3cc87c5b4c5f78be4b2efa4c5830a1b

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1jRcFtcraxsmgGwpi7as9kXRy2Y_bwWwe:substantive-completion:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1jRcFtcraxsmgGwpi7as9kXRy2Y_bwWwe:substantive-completion:033:prayer

PRAYER FOR RELIEF
32. WHEREFORE, Defendant respectfully requests that this Court:
33. A. Take judicial notice of this objection and cease all further proceedings in this case until the pending Motion to Disqualify has been ruled upon and overruled of record;
34. B. Issue a ruling on the disqualification motion on the papers, without hearing or further personal appearance by Defendant before the challenged judge;
35. C. Vacate and strike the May 28, 2025 setting (which the docket describes only as “status on hearing” and contains no appearance order), and order that no appearance is required until the disqualification matter is resolved; and
36. D. Grant such other relief as may be just, proper, and necessary to protect Defendant’s rights and uphold the integrity of the judicial process.

Exact text SHA-256 2b5eba1159ce18f12ecee7c92d32e8aaf7dd827a3cbd27e2d3cdd344f56291c9

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1jRcFtcraxsmgGwpi7as9kXRy2Y_bwWwe:substantive-completion:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1jRcFtcraxsmgGwpi7as9kXRy2Y_bwWwe:substantive-completion:033:closing

Respectfully submitted,

Exact text SHA-256 a0fee356f8359873a75bc863c27fd771648ca8a4ec219caa0325ef2a71e1830b

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1jRcFtcraxsmgGwpi7as9kXRy2Y_bwWwe:substantive-completion:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1jRcFtcraxsmgGwpi7as9kXRy2Y_bwWwe:substantive-completion:033:dated-line

Dated: May 20, 2025

Exact text SHA-256 8d0caebc7522598c833dbef4bc92efcde435d13dbe97633e73f026287ac07307

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1jRcFtcraxsmgGwpi7as9kXRy2Y_bwWwe:substantive-completion:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1jRcFtcraxsmgGwpi7as9kXRy2Y_bwWwe:substantive-completion:033:certificate

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I certify that on May 20, 2025, I mailed this motion to the Washington County Court Clerk with a request that a copy be placed in both the District Attorney’s box and the box of the Honorable Judge Jared Sigler.
Respectfully submitted,

Exact text SHA-256 362d3bdd9e95e0582da3f968a7fd3a16fb03de4bfda0536168e3d5ca594a14fc