The Oklahoma Fugitive

Record archive

DEFENDANT'S REPLY TO STATE'S RESPONSE TO MOTION TO DISMISS (COPY PUT IN DA'S BOX)

Source-owning proceeding: CM-2024-00301 · Existing document identity: DOC-1084658893

Existing contextual aliases: D21. Aliases do not establish provenance.

View original PDF Download unchanged original

Unmodified, unredacted retained PDF; 8 physical page/image position(s), 532374 bytes.

Original and shipped SHA-256 f60fee952b6bebb1c6367784d54cd603b5ccb723855fddba70eb8beb0130886a

Separate docket appearances

A docket entry is distinct from the source-owned original document. Cross-proceeding entries link to this single original; no second authoritative copy is created.

CM-2024-00301 · ROW-047 · entry date as printed: 04/09/2025

Existing text coverage and recorded date roles

Only the listed existing permitted passages are searchable. Original images/PDFs and existing omissions remain unchanged; no OCR or inferred complete text. Representations remain separate and passages retain their existing source order/locators. No inferred continuous page transcription.

Inherited transcription/review notes describe prior source review, including any wording such as “this session”; no new transcription was performed for this export.

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033

Selected existing passages

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033:p1:b1

IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF WASHINGTON COUNTY
STATE OF OKLAHOMA
THE STATE OF OKLAHOMA,
Plaintiff,
v.
FLYNN ROBERT MARTIN,
Defendant.
Case No. CM-2024-00301

Exact text SHA-256 49ae33fb6b0c6e34c053dbeb199f3f220f995a4b02475a887886d33a84237107

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033:p1:b2

FILED
APR 09 2025

Exact text SHA-256 337022cfea8e6afe1fef5febe4282b024b033df15c26cac2d5710fd18f0550b0

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033:p1:b3

DEFENDANT’S REPLY TO STATE’S RESPONSE TO MOTION TO DISMISS
(Brought Pursuant to 22 O.S. § 504(4): Facial Demurrer to the Information)
(Defendant Appearing Pro Se)

Exact text SHA-256 6f25575a7b857f634160e5516c6a66a0c2978302e3e664cb196e1268c71411eb

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033:p1:b4

Procedural Recap
Defendant was arrested on July 5, 2024, and initially charged with possession of a Schedule II controlled dangerous substance under 63 O.S. § 2-402. On September 5, 2024, the Oklahoma State Bureau of Investigation (OSBI) issued a Criminalistics Examination Report. On December 31, 2024, the State filed a First Amended Information, again citing 63 O.S. § 2-402, but this time alleging possession of a fictitious Schedule II substance: “tetrahydrocannabinolis”—a term not recognized under any Oklahoma statute or schedule.

Exact text SHA-256 93e56c5e3286f906d81d2bcabffbc3caf15ddc8915db95a32cb0c02994170fe4

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033:p1:b5

Defendant’s former counsel filed a Motion to Dismiss on January 10, 2025. The State filed its Response on February 26, 2025. A hearing on the motion, originally scheduled for March 4, 2025, was postponed due to defense counsel’s illness and inability to proceed. Defendant has since been granted leave by the Court to represent himself pro se.

Exact text SHA-256 e526b6e43a9a8df45dfc89b19e19c0dc867215d9f8595987c7f6a8482315adc4

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033:p1:b6

I. Correction and Clarification of Prior Motion
A. Formal Recantation & Procedural Clarification
Defendant formally recants and explicitly withdraws all arguments previously advanced by former counsel that went beyond the facial content of the Information. Specifically, Defendant now withdraws any prior reliance upon arguments related to chemical analysis or distinctions between cannabinoids (THCA vs. THC), administrative definitions under the

Exact text SHA-256 1499c59e9482d3966dc93443bef5a1cfa7bb350878704b50c186bb048a8153f0

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033:p2:b1

Defendant now withdraws any prior reliance upon arguments related to chemical analysis or distinctions between cannabinoids (THCA vs. THC), administrative definitions under the Oklahoma Medical Marijuana Authority (OMMA), federal agricultural statutes, and constitutional claims. These extraneous issues are immaterial to the instant jurisdictional challenge.

Exact text SHA-256 f7e0008e19154db57468427aaf2d0e88a3e5352399b0f21e8718483807343650

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033:p2:b2

Defendant explicitly recants and withdraws former counsel's erroneous reference to "tetrahydrocannabinols" and the incorrect citation to Schedule III substances in the previously filed Motion to Dismiss, as these inaccuracies are immaterial, misleading, and irrelevant to the instant jurisdictional challenge.

Exact text SHA-256 0d03ec579643cb4eeb3f1abbd5f33d5299a28abb861c2ff811f07b044366f80d

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033:p2:b3

Instead, Defendant explicitly asserts a facial demurrer to the Information pursuant to 22 O.S. § 504(4), on grounds that the Information, on its face, fails to allege facts constituting a public offense recognized under Oklahoma law. This defect is jurisdictional and subject to a demurrer as a pure question of law, requiring no evidentiary consideration.¹

Exact text SHA-256 7bf98a49249b0c674338c6f6f1be2191eef49a519cde1f095467cfa73877a7d2

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033:p2:b4

Defendant further confirms that this demurrer is now explicitly stated in writing and distinctly specifies its statutory grounds, fully complying with the procedural requirements mandated by 22 O.S. § 505. Thus, any prior ambiguity or omission of specificity from former counsel’s motion is now cured, properly teeing up this facial, jurisdictional challenge for the Court’s consideration.²

Exact text SHA-256 0466a8282e62ae32abc0946d6e1443a340653388e3ebcb0ad9398f36a73dcb1b

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033:p2:b5

Footnotes – Section I.A
¹ State v. Hudson, 2022 OK CR 28, ¶5, 520 P.3d 388, 390 (holding that a facially defective Information presents a jurisdictional defect properly challenged by demurrer under 22 O.S. § 504(4)).
² 22 O.S. § 505 (explicitly requiring a demurrer to be in writing and distinctly specify grounds of objection).

Exact text SHA-256 0b9510359e1792575ba6b0ee0b4ba77462bef750b3f9add0572215425bb03246

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033:p2:b6

B. Accurate Identification of Statutory Charge
Defendant explicitly clarifies that the First Amended Information alleges possession of a controlled substance described as “tetrahydrocannabinolis,” a term wholly absent from Oklahoma’s Uniform Controlled Dangerous Substances Act and not appearing in any statutory schedule. Oklahoma law requires an Information to clearly and distinctly articulate the alleged offense using language understandable by ordinary individuals and precisely matched to statutory definitions (22 O.S. §§ 401–409).¹
Here, the Information plainly fails these statutory requirements, charging Defendant with a nonexistent substance. Oklahoma criminal statutes must be strictly construed, and defendants cannot lawfully be prosecuted based on fictitious or imaginary substances or terms invented by prosecutorial error.² Such statutory ambiguity renders the Information facially deficient as a matter of law, compelling immediate dismissal under the controlling precedent.³

Exact text SHA-256 fceadf7210cd196d82f041294bf6fa5cb28ee7317213df9985deffd8e8fe57c5

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033:p2:b7

Footnotes – Section I.B
¹ 22 O.S. §§ 401–409 (explicitly mandating clarity, specificity, and statutory conformity in charging language).
² Fenimore v. State, 2003 OK CR 20, ¶5, 78 P.3d 549, 551 (criminal statutes must be strictly construed and cannot be expanded beyond clear statutory language).
³ State v. Tran, 2007 OK CR 39, ¶8, 172 P.3d 199, 202–03 (charging instruments may not rely on statutory splicing or invented language to allege crimes).

Exact text SHA-256 6eb753e8d7a5f7c2cdf8067e69c6236cda6c4cc2b9abc72081231bd7bff89952

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033:p3:b1

II. Dispositive Threshold Argument: Facial Failure to Allege a Public Offense
A. Requirements for a Valid Information under Oklahoma Law
Oklahoma law imposes strict requirements for the content of a valid criminal Information. Under 22 O.S. §§ 401–409, an Information must allege a public offense in ordinary and concise language, using statutorily defined terms, and in such a manner that enables a person of common understanding to know what is intended.¹ The charging document must also be sufficiently clear to allow the court to pronounce judgment if a conviction results.²

Exact text SHA-256 a21d735dc4824fa11bcbbd408581aeb133e06db80b39f4f2df9356b9d5456cf6

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033:p3:b2

The First Amended Information fails these requirements. It alleges possession of “tetrahydrocannabinolis,” a term not defined by statute, not listed in any controlled substance schedule, and not recognized under Oklahoma law. Its use renders the charge facially unintelligible, both to Defendant and the Court.

Exact text SHA-256 8fa3e8048d9c29d5c4737bfa7a557ff1a45bd7a0f8170a72c11ecc96311cf7bd

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033:p3:b3

Oklahoma courts require strict construction of criminal statutes and charging instruments. As the Court held in Fenimore v. State, courts may not expand the meaning of statutory terms or invent crimes not clearly defined by law.³ Similarly, in State v. Tran, the Court explicitly prohibited the State from creating criminal liability through the manipulation or splicing of unrelated statutory language.⁴

Exact text SHA-256 e260b4e1946d73c9b7ec532a16ca56e320637e6d3da4607716daef8223bce9c8

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033:p3:b4

Because the First Amended Information lacks any reference to a real, scheduled substance, and uses fictitious terminology not found in law, it fails to state a public offense and is facially defective. Dismissal is required as a matter of law.

Exact text SHA-256 813a850320ffb2e5c9564753430caf52fbc4d31765737f636bb2c167b762b753

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033:p3:b5

Footnotes – Section II.A
¹ 22 O.S. § 401; see also §§ 402–409 (collectively requiring clarity, certainty, and statutory grounding in all charging instruments).
² 22 O.S. § 409 (Information must be sufficient to support a lawful judgment of conviction).
³ Fenimore v. State, 2003 OK CR 20, ¶ 5, 78 P.3d 549, 551 (criminal statutes strictly construed; no enlargement by implication).
⁴ State v. Tran, 2007 OK CR 39, ¶ 8, 172 P.3d 199, 203 (criminal charges must derive from clearly stated legislative enactments; statutory splicing is impermissible).

Exact text SHA-256 b8f43abc1e10e553a4b53edeb7547b2dd64a450059361f27089ca26744e4e87c

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033:p3:b6

B. Jurisdictional Consequences of Alleging a Nonexistent Offense
An Information alleging a nonexistent statutory offense fails, on its face, to confer subject-matter jurisdiction upon the Court. Oklahoma law clearly mandates that the State must charge a legally cognizable offense as a prerequisite to jurisdiction; where no valid public offense is alleged, the defect is jurisdictional, irreparable, and mandates immediate dismissal.¹

Exact text SHA-256 6e21b166762a71ed66cef068a76b7dd2afcc5d68587e6ef3f0bb49069fa7d976

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033:p3:b7

As explicitly held by the Oklahoma Court of Criminal Appeals in State v. Hudson, a facially defective Information that does not charge a statutory offense constitutes a jurisdictional flaw depriving the Court of authority to proceed.² Such a defect cannot be cured by amendment or supplemented by inference or implication. The jurisdictional deficiency, therefore, compels the Court to sustain Defendant’s demurrer under 22 O.S. § 504(4) and immediately dismiss the prosecution with prejudice.

Exact text SHA-256 c70f968abe419b02be57b5221ad0995b16116d1556a898111368141d3907e3a8

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033:p4:b1

C. Material Prejudice from the State’s Amendment of the Information
Defendant has suffered material prejudice resulting directly from the State’s filing of the First Amended Information on December 31, 2024, nearly six months after Defendant’s initial arrest (07/05/2024) and over three months after issuance of the OSBI Criminalistics Examination Report (09/05/2024). Critically, this amendment was filed only after significant procedural events had occurred, including a status conference (10/09/2024), a jury trial sounding docket (12/19/2024)—wherein the Court explicitly set a trial date of January 27, 2025, and a motion cutoff date of January 10, 2025—just ten days after the filing of the amended Information.

Exact text SHA-256 0e267396d6b718339251cd2eb118dfb6059636a919016dd325bcf3d2be865cf0

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033:p4:b2

This late amendment, introducing the fictitious and legally unrecognized controlled substance “tetrahydrocannabinolis,” directly undermined Defendant’s ability to adequately prepare a defense within the already limited timeframe provided by the Court’s scheduling order. Defendant was further prejudiced by required subsequent appearances at a January 10, 2025 cutoff hearing and January 22, 2025 status hearing, both conducted without clarity regarding the amended charge. The State compounded the ambiguity by explicitly defending its flawed position in its February 26, 2025 Response Brief and reasserting it at the subsequent hearing on March 4, 2025, further prolonging the prejudicial confusion and uncertainty.

Exact text SHA-256 e61e6838727ce12025d6c5afc040ca4e913f958fd6db4cfa7f32780adb3838a1

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033:p4:b3

Thus, from the belated amendment filed on December 31, 2024, continuously through the present (04/09/2025), Defendant has been materially prejudiced by procedural ambiguity and insufficient notice, impairing effective defense preparation. Under Oklahoma law, amendments causing procedural confusion or materially hindering defense preparation, particularly when filed shortly before trial and cutoff dates, constitute impermissible prejudice that mandates immediate dismissal.¹ The State’s amendment in this case precisely meets the standard for impermissible prejudice articulated in Shiever v. State and related Oklahoma authorities.²

Exact text SHA-256 9eba0ca3aba5d3af111034fe8df3912d22bef9e52b7f624caa7cc6d65f01bff6

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033:p4:b4

Footnotes – Section II.C
¹ Shiever v. State, 1951 OK CR 100, 234 P.2d 921, 94 Okl. Cr. 279 (amendments permissible only absent material prejudice).
² See also Arms v. State, 49 Okla. Cr. 34, 292 P. 76 (1927); Ward v. State, 34 Okla. Cr. 296, 246 P. 664 (1926); Hammons v. State, 47 Okla. Cr. 297, 287 P. 1076 (1930); Little v. State, 21 Okla. Cr. 1, 204 P. 305 (1922); Knopp v. State, 59 Okla. Cr. 143, 56 P.2d 1193 (1936) (amendments impermissible when they cause confusion or prejudice defendant’s ability to adequately respond, especially when timing impacts trial preparation).

Exact text SHA-256 e1dd35715be709712257521372f65bf564694f98e9421161b11497534167c305

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033:p4:b5

III. Preservation of the Record – Concise Rebuttal to State’s Four Arguments

Exact text SHA-256 03588f91d4fc3c7f1e5a905a5234f4250acc9c27cba04c3c46b925139eb97a50

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033:p4:b6

A. Misapplication of Civil Procedure & Improper Burden-Shifting
The State improperly invokes civil procedural standards under 12 O.S. § 577, erroneously treating Defendant’s demurrer as if it were a civil demurrer to evidence. Defendant’s motion is correctly raised under criminal procedure, specifically a facial demurrer pursuant to 22 O.S. § 504(4). This statute explicitly governs criminal proceedings and places no evidentiary burden whatsoever upon Defendant at this stage. Rather, it mandates a purely legal determination based solely upon the face of the Information itself.¹ The State’s reliance

Exact text SHA-256 b9244be1107ebcc7db6d169bcf355e4bcc1d8b0a68d21971c2c654618420a27a

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033:p5:b1

on civil statutes to shift an improper evidentiary burden onto Defendant is misplaced and legally incorrect.

Exact text SHA-256 7034681054db6039e6bcb5303359b008e254b2cdcea84ab90031061d0edf0c02

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033:p5:b2

Footnotes – Section III.A
¹ State v. Hudson, 2022 OK CR 28, ¶5, 520 P.3d 388, 390 (holding a facial demurrer under 22 O.S. § 504(4) presents a purely legal issue with no evidentiary burden on Defendant).

Exact text SHA-256 ccb4f736e67201ba56a67367f1e3aa04fd048cf7f6d69eb0485f636e5022b916

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033:p5:b3

B. Incorrect Statutory Citation & Reliance on Fictitious Terminology
The State improperly attempts to rehabilitate its defective charge by substituting the fictitious term “tetrahydrocannibols” into statutory language explicitly reserved for anabolic steroids under 63 O.S. § 2-208(D)(2). The actual wording of this statute specifically enumerates “hormonal substances or steroids, including their salts, isomers, esters...” but contains no reference whatsoever to tetrahydrocannibols or any similarly named substance.

Exact text SHA-256 4ba57751a3fc5b0be24990d9ebe905746d8629954fb4ef20ae3d7b9e14e89fea

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033:p5:b4

Moreover, the First Amended Information explicitly labels the charged substance (“tetrahydrocannabinolis”) as a Schedule II controlled dangerous substance, despite the fact that the State’s arguments rely upon language from a separate Schedule III provision (63 O.S. § 2-208). Criminal statutes must be narrowly construed; prosecutors may not invent offenses or expand statutory language beyond explicit legislative authorization.¹ ²

Exact text SHA-256 a345fc5dc0e6407116e50282cb1e0041c6393799454d285b5dee2724ae2657d1

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033:p5:b5

Therefore, the State’s attempt to salvage its facially defective charge by invoking unrelated statutory references only further underscores the fatal ambiguity and statutory invalidity of the amended Information.

Exact text SHA-256 d4836998c99502ae5d301f167b97d11c5b012db068e181fc57218e626a0ed169

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033:p5:b6

Footnotes – Section III.B
¹ State v. Tran, 2007 OK CR 39, ¶8, 172 P.3d 199, 202–03 (charging instruments must derive from clear statutory enactments and cannot rely on language lifted from unrelated provisions).
² Fenimore v. State, 2003 OK CR 20, ¶5, 78 P.3d 549, 551 (criminal statutes strictly construed; no authority to expand or rewrite statutory language).

Exact text SHA-256 0847a3a488cab1ce68508dc4894c63b4d511af33b7b6395300df96152c175f66

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033:p5:b7

C. Defective Substance Terminology
The State’s third argument relies on fictitious and legally undefined terminology, including the terms “tetrahydrocannibols” and “tetrahydrocannibolic acid.” Neither of these terms appears in any Oklahoma statute, regulatory definition, or controlled substance schedule. Their use not only compounds the ambiguity created by the First Amended Information’s reference to “tetrahydrocannabinolis,” but further demonstrates the State’s inability to identify any actual scheduled substance prohibited under Oklahoma law.

Exact text SHA-256 2666e1ab015d2e4628506aae7d2a43ad973f985569d93810cccfb2ff16562fca

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033:p5:b8

Oklahoma courts have made clear that criminal statutes must be strictly construed, and that no person may be prosecuted for conduct not clearly proscribed by statute.¹ The charging instrument must use statutorily defined terms or their equivalent.² The State’s reliance on fabricated or hybridized terminology violates this principle and reinforces the conclusion that the Information, on its face, fails to allege a cognizable offense.

Exact text SHA-256 5ff7a75feb39b05b0cfc702a78d30bf34b8e57301a1b3dbb02440834c41ca817

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033:p5:b9

Footnotes – Section III.C
¹ Fenimore v. State, 2003 OK CR 20, ¶5, 78 P.3d 549, 551 (criminal statutes must be strictly construed against the State and cannot be expanded to include conduct not expressly prohibited).

Exact text SHA-256 3f802b40a23a4dd745784f1146202be6d1863a5fcdf56492df335184e6428728

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033:p6:b1

² State v. Tran, 2007 OK CR 39, ¶8, 172 P.3d 199, 203 (rejecting efforts to create new offenses by inference or misapplication of statutory language).

Exact text SHA-256 9b9855e99d209c8ee69f03d08c1456d30958930018c10c49be2b0d6a13f81b9b

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033:p6:b2

D. Incorrect Requirement of Evidentiary Development
The State incorrectly asserts that Defendant’s challenge cannot be resolved without the development of an evidentiary record. This misstates the nature of a facial demurrer under 22 O.S. § 504(4). A demurrer of this kind presents a pure question of law and is evaluated solely on the face of the Information, without consideration of any underlying facts or evidence.

Exact text SHA-256 c775302292b373e0261e5921a085513c91984102720e65938491cecb98fd62ff

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033:p6:b3

As reaffirmed by the Oklahoma Court of Criminal Appeals in State v. Hudson, a demurrer alleging that the Information fails to state a public offense does not require evidentiary development or factual resolution.¹ The Court must determine only whether, assuming the allegations to be true, the Information charges a legally cognizable offense under Oklahoma law. Because the First Amended Information alleges a fictitious substance not found in any statutory schedule, it fails this test as a matter of law.

Exact text SHA-256 0f93c67b397df5ded5adb1ec50bb680fd0ff9943cabc007633cfa4a0cdc6a845

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033:p6:b4

Footnotes – Section III.D
¹ State v. Hudson, 2022 OK CR 28, ¶5, 520 P.3d 388, 390 (facial demurrer under § 504(4) raises a legal question resolved solely on the charging instrument’s face; evidentiary record not required).

Exact text SHA-256 7d96d4c933fc177ddc60408bd21f8b9d3017f028e7f8fe03ae9f0732c5f69466

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033:p6:b5

IV. Court’s Mandatory Statutory Duty to Dismiss with Prejudice

Exact text SHA-256 4b996dcd587ab08ae6ccee25a35bbc2b755c397d82e81e77e47ea89fb1a6b2c3

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033:p6:b6

Because the First Amended Information fails, on its face, to allege a public offense, the Court is statutorily required to sustain Defendant’s demurrer and dismiss the prosecution with prejudice. Under 22 O.S. § 504(4), a demurrer must be sustained where the facts stated do not constitute a public offense. Once sustained, dismissal is mandatory under 22 O.S. § 508, unless the Court expressly finds that the defect may be cured by filing a valid new Information.

Exact text SHA-256 8b9b7671fad3c209d4e7de69bc03449e26d22501a78198f57737574df037af13

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033:p6:b7

Here, no such cure is possible. The charged substance—“tetrahydrocannabinolis”—is fictitious and legally nonexistent. Substituting or amending the Information to allege a new, different substance at this stage would constitute the initiation of a separate prosecution, not a curable defect. Finality is required where the defect is fundamental and jurisdictional, as it is here.

Exact text SHA-256 452c54f7f5d3a80fcbc3ebe18b0e0371dbdfc2670ea374c95b8210f7ced1f119

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033:p6:b8

Oklahoma law strictly limits prosecutorial discretion in these circumstances. As the Court explained in State v. Young, once a demurrer is sustained and the trial court does not direct refiling, dismissal operates as a final bar to further prosecution.¹ This is reinforced by 22 O.S. § 849, which mandates that if no offense is stated, the defendant must be discharged.²

Exact text SHA-256 e5ca41b736a6f1383e8c2fca499b87a74fbbb8e1dc7c94ca76de775e93924a52

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033:p6:b9

Accordingly, the Court’s duty is clear. The First Amended Information fails to state a public offense, the defect is incurable, and dismissal with prejudice is required as a matter of law.

Exact text SHA-256 11fb678d754f14c44a747eb3ba0968d1e470094e0a765dea7caadf266facfccd

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033:p7:b1

Footnotes – Section IV
¹ State v. Young, 1994 OK CR 25, ¶6, 874 P.2d 57, 59 (dismissal following a sustained demurrer is final unless the court expressly authorizes refiling under 22 O.S. § 508).
² State v. Hudson, 2022 OK CR 28, ¶5, 520 P.3d 388, 390 (courts lack jurisdiction to proceed where no public offense is stated; dismissal required under §§ 504(4), 849).

Exact text SHA-256 6aecfdb966f5dd878925416e1ad50791661715e2efc91c8c694fa782a8edd5ba

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033:p7:b2

Prayer for Relief
WHEREFORE, for the reasons set forth above, Defendant respectfully prays that this Court:
1. Sustain the demurrer pursuant to 22 O.S. § 504(4) on the ground that the First Amended Information fails, on its face, to allege a public offense under Oklahoma law;

Exact text SHA-256 0261bfe84cdfc6e93bc65d0f7fcd607e0c9185d7d774076b529737f6f83f5b98

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033:p7:b3

2. Enter an order dismissing the Information with prejudice in accordance with 22 O.S. §§ 504(4), 505, 508, and 849, as the defect is jurisdictional and incurable;

Exact text SHA-256 2d95ab6218d8e129cfd8e998cbdbd01ca07bbad8c0560f0b6a9bfbb096ebd909

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033:p7:b4

3. Declare the First Amended Information void as a matter of law and of no further legal effect;

Exact text SHA-256 2a7bdd641c45e416eebf2e67d1b6e2ac4ac8637b478912e48bf7caf2176f4b54

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033:p7:b5

4. Bar further prosecution under the defective charging instrument, and decline to authorize the filing of any amended or substitute Information alleging a new offense; and

Exact text SHA-256 880578475a3416a2a69adccefbd46cc97b33d9cb0bc33fde469e2d44d3fe30d4

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033:p7:b6

5. Grant such other and further relief as the Court deems just and proper under the laws of the State of Oklahoma.

Exact text SHA-256 4e94d49decd79f26327ba43f4f3efc0e524ea83daaf1bc47fb0d9841849ae455

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033:p7:b7

Respectfully submitted,
Flynn Robert Martin
Defendant, Pro Se
Dated: April 9, 2025

Exact text SHA-256 20753668eb8500fc24fe51c93f065f1eacb71fb515e121b8660e6f2c61586dc0

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033:p8:b1

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

Exact text SHA-256 3dc19f7617308076d8a0c8c58aee55aacb18e38102b852c1a51925819f27503f

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033:p8:b2

I hereby certify that on this 9th day of April, 2025, a true and correct copy of the foregoing Defendant’s Reply to State’s Response to Motion to Dismiss was delivered to:

Exact text SHA-256 e01d22f6db809b6f175214c69571410655778d2146e8b0853487bc129659dccc

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033:p8:b3

Washington County District Attorney’s Office

Exact text SHA-256 2f3526a3d8a950326b0e3626600b610a35246941835f39d5ea012e55b2c57f25

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1TAHsy7M9PSjYGJjlQjkxMjBtt-84VQn8:readiness033:p8:b4

Flynn Robert Martin
Defendant, Pro Se

Exact text SHA-256 997fd7289ac32698ec517789ee93f83275df19c37e2879b621b014cc9396df63