The Oklahoma Fugitive

Record archive

DEMURRER TO ORIGINAL INFORMATION (FROM PRO-SE DEFENDANT)

Source-owning proceeding: CM-2024-00301 · Existing document identity: DOC-1085899384

Existing contextual aliases: D48. Aliases do not establish provenance.

View original PDF Download unchanged original

Unmodified, unredacted retained PDF; 6 physical page/image position(s), 123818 bytes.

Original and shipped SHA-256 c9c783dae958b1e6b0489cc6a2396c262f05fa59687d253fa807e47edcf5259a

Separate docket appearances

A docket entry is distinct from the source-owned original document. Cross-proceeding entries link to this single original; no second authoritative copy is created.

CM-2024-00301 · ROW-077 · entry date as printed: 08/22/2025

Existing text coverage and recorded date roles

Only the listed existing permitted passages are searchable. Original images/PDFs and existing omissions remain unchanged; no OCR or inferred complete text. Representations remain separate and passages retain their existing source order/locators. No inferred continuous page transcription.

Inherited transcription/review notes describe prior source review, including any wording such as “this session”; no new transcription was performed for this export.

record:ASSET-DRIVE-11y6DY9zmZwnXLc2DQH8cOrHQw324q_ME:reviewed-substantive:033

Selected existing passages

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-11y6DY9zmZwnXLc2DQH8cOrHQw324q_ME:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-11y6DY9zmZwnXLc2DQH8cOrHQw324q_ME:reviewed-substantive:033:p1:1

DEMURRER TO ORIGINAL INFORMATION

Exact text SHA-256 6483b85152ffb4334f717d6eaa257759d60a4e9a3d31255ae8f28d37a49bd2ce

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-11y6DY9zmZwnXLc2DQH8cOrHQw324q_ME:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-11y6DY9zmZwnXLc2DQH8cOrHQw324q_ME:reviewed-substantive:033:p1:2

COMES NOW the Defendant, Flynn Robert Martin, appearing pro se, and pursuant to 22 O.S. § 504(4), demurs to the Original Information filed July 5, 2024 on the ground that the facts stated do not constitute a public offense. In the alternative, Defendant demurs under 22 O.S. § 504(3) because the single count charges more than one offense. Arraignment proceeded on this instrument on July 8, 2024. Defendant does not concede that any other charging paper is operative. Defendant respectfully asks the Court to sustain this demurrer, declare the Original Information invalid and non-operative, and enter the statutory relief, including dismissal under 22 O.S. § 508 and discharge/exoneration under 22 O.S. § 509.

Exact text SHA-256 391f022ffa534f528f9f1e9e04ba367e1abe4dcd700006d4c1d88eee99d656f7

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-11y6DY9zmZwnXLc2DQH8cOrHQw324q_ME:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-11y6DY9zmZwnXLc2DQH8cOrHQw324q_ME:reviewed-substantive:033:p2:1

I. INTRODUCTION

Exact text SHA-256 511b20a4e6b07129dc8c2af532c53daaf6d78e8a75652bd60b8dae23cb7288b7

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-11y6DY9zmZwnXLc2DQH8cOrHQw324q_ME:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-11y6DY9zmZwnXLc2DQH8cOrHQw324q_ME:reviewed-substantive:033:p2:2

The Original Information filed to initiate the proceedings in this case does not invoke jurisdiction because it fails, on its face, to identify a single, statutorily recognized controlled substance. The instrument describes the substance three different ways—its caption parenthetical reads “(AMPHETAMINE/OPIODS),” its count title reads “(AMPHETAMINE),” and its narrative alleges “AMPHETAMINE and/or OPIODS, said drug … Schedule II.” The narrative’s use of “and/or” to alternate between different substances, followed by a singular reference to “said drug,” leaves the identity element unfixed and prevents the charge from stating one public offense with the certainty Oklahoma law requires.

Exact text SHA-256 f1165de90c5ce7306089fcb270a2e9ffc9efc7a8b13e1c9b300f9c4c09087e53

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-11y6DY9zmZwnXLc2DQH8cOrHQw324q_ME:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-11y6DY9zmZwnXLc2DQH8cOrHQw324q_ME:reviewed-substantive:033:p2:3

Independently, the term “OPIODS” is not a listed identity anywhere in the Uniform Controlled Dangerous Substances Act. The schedules enumerate specific substances and classes, but they do not recognize “opiods” as a controlled substance. Because the identity of the controlled dangerous substance is an essential element that must match a statutorily enumerated listing, the pleading fails to state a public offense and cannot invoke this Court’s power to proceed. In the alternative, alleging “amphetamine and/or opiods” while referring to a single “said drug” charges more than one offense in a single count. The demurrer should be sustained and the statutory remedies entered.

Exact text SHA-256 90c4d54a403657d96acec8e638ee50021dd336e38b747483fafda22dded1da40

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-11y6DY9zmZwnXLc2DQH8cOrHQw324q_ME:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-11y6DY9zmZwnXLc2DQH8cOrHQw324q_ME:reviewed-substantive:033:p2:4

II. LEGAL STANDARD

Exact text SHA-256 defc4a774e948456d4162d0ba89780513cef61ef3d29ac4148b56563d443eab4

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-11y6DY9zmZwnXLc2DQH8cOrHQw324q_ME:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-11y6DY9zmZwnXLc2DQH8cOrHQw324q_ME:reviewed-substantive:033:p2:5

An Information must allege every essential element of a single public offense in ordinary and concise language sufficient to identify the offense and provide fair notice. If an essential element is not alleged with legal certainty, the Information fails to state a public offense and does not

Exact text SHA-256 8f03a384440ff92c03fed0abb7d64f92b624c6494e19a86649f031baa7324abe

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-11y6DY9zmZwnXLc2DQH8cOrHQw324q_ME:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-11y6DY9zmZwnXLc2DQH8cOrHQw324q_ME:reviewed-substantive:033:p3:1

invoke jurisdiction.¹ A demurrer is the statutorily prescribed vehicle to attack a facially defective Information. It is a challenge that goes to the subject matter jurisdiction of the Court, it is non-waivable; it may be raised after arraignment, at trial, or even in arrest of judgment.²

Exact text SHA-256 69febd04d7a0e0d229fe7bdff0152e630643c0814a7d022865c46e4a9d979fb2

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-11y6DY9zmZwnXLc2DQH8cOrHQw324q_ME:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-11y6DY9zmZwnXLc2DQH8cOrHQw324q_ME:reviewed-substantive:033:p3:2

The identity of the controlled dangerous substance is a material element that must correspond to a substance enumerated in the statutory schedules.³ Oklahoma’s Uniform Controlled Dangerous Substances Act codifies those schedules as follows: Schedule I; Schedule II; Schedule III; Schedule IV; and Schedule V.⁴ If the named substance is not listed under the schedule alleged, the Information omits an essential element on its face and is demurrable.

Exact text SHA-256 05625699e03621d07229d4b80d6e83fcd39080942a9561a666a06ad426a5c79c

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-11y6DY9zmZwnXLc2DQH8cOrHQw324q_ME:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-11y6DY9zmZwnXLc2DQH8cOrHQw324q_ME:reviewed-substantive:033:p3:3

The defendant may demur on the ground that more than one offense is charged or that the facts stated do not constitute a public offense.⁵ A demurrer must be written, signed, filed, and must distinctly specify its grounds.⁶ Once filed, the objections must be heard promptly, and the court must enter an order sustaining or overruling the demurrer.⁷ If sustained, the judgment is final upon the Information and bars reprosecution unless the court directs that a new Information be filed; if no further prosecution is directed, the defendant must be discharged and bail exonerated.⁸

Exact text SHA-256 fa7deed1fe123235ad501af0d25eba69b9646a81a7ced3c4c2ed25abe8a8eb9e

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-11y6DY9zmZwnXLc2DQH8cOrHQw324q_ME:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-11y6DY9zmZwnXLc2DQH8cOrHQw324q_ME:reviewed-substantive:033:p3:4

¹ 22 O.S. §§ 401–409 (form and sufficiency requirements for indictments and informations).
² 22 O.S. § 504(4) (demurrer proper where “the facts stated do not constitute a public offense”); 22 O.S. § 512 (lack of subject-matter jurisdiction and § 504(4) defects may be raised after arraignment, at trial, or in arrest of judgment).
³ OUJI-CR 6-6 (identity of [Name of Substance] is an element); See also 63 O.S. § 2-101(11) (defining “controlled dangerous substance” by reference to Schedules I–V).
⁴ 63 O.S. §§ 2-203, 2-204 (Schedule I), §§ 2-205, 2-206 (Schedule II), §§ 2-207, 2-208 (Schedule III), §§ 2-209, 2-210 (Schedule IV), §§ 2-211, 2-212 (Schedule V).
⁵ § 504(3) (demurrer proper where “more than one offense is charged”); § 504(4), supra note 2.
⁶ 22 O.S. § 505 (demurrer must be in writing, signed, filed, and distinctly specify grounds).
⁷ 22 O.S. §§ 506–507 (court must hear demurrer and enter judgment sustaining or overruling).
⁸ 22 O.S. §§ 508–509 (effect of sustaining; discharge/exoneration if further prosecution not directed).

Exact text SHA-256 015a950b30553317e061e9a78b45c1c48533da05c96dfdad31a91981452dff68

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-11y6DY9zmZwnXLc2DQH8cOrHQw324q_ME:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-11y6DY9zmZwnXLc2DQH8cOrHQw324q_ME:reviewed-substantive:033:p4:1

III. GROUNDS FOR DEMURRER

Exact text SHA-256 f5ecfedac8eff02ff7877cc10a6def46b34453acf724575f4c1255c6bcc8b552

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-11y6DY9zmZwnXLc2DQH8cOrHQw324q_ME:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-11y6DY9zmZwnXLc2DQH8cOrHQw324q_ME:reviewed-substantive:033:p4:2

A. Primary Ground — 22 O.S. § 504(4)

Exact text SHA-256 62a0eaa999df429fe118349c97f56f5a48be9b44c5399f624c958c569a2719d1

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-11y6DY9zmZwnXLc2DQH8cOrHQw324q_ME:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-11y6DY9zmZwnXLc2DQH8cOrHQw324q_ME:reviewed-substantive:033:p4:3

The Original Information is facially inconsistent and fails to allege a single public offense. In the caption parenthetical it recites “(AMPHETAMINE/OPIODS),” in the count title it states “(AMPHETAMINE),” and in the narrative it alleges “AMPHETAMINE and/or OPIODS, said drug … Schedule II.” ⁹ These contradictions leave the identity element unfixed. The narrative in particular purports to alternate between two different substances by the phrase “and/or,” yet then refers to “said drug” in the singular, obscuring which offense is actually charged and preventing the instrument from identifying one statutorily defined substance as required.¹⁰

Exact text SHA-256 79ca19e5431f7930146ae794ae6cde2ffb800a6e69f772380fc2eb5adf6ca22a

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-11y6DY9zmZwnXLc2DQH8cOrHQw324q_ME:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-11y6DY9zmZwnXLc2DQH8cOrHQw324q_ME:reviewed-substantive:033:p4:4

Separately—and dispositively—the term “OPIODS” is not a statutorily recognized controlled dangerous substance in Oklahoma law. The word “opiods” as it appears on the face of the Information is not found anywhere in the Uniform Controlled Dangerous Substances Act as a listed substance or schedule entry.¹¹ Because the identity of the controlled substance is an essential element, and because the pleading does not allege a single substance that is actually enumerated under the schedule it invokes, the information fails on its face to state a public offense within the meaning of § 504(4).¹² The defect is jurisdictional and may be raised at any time.¹³

Exact text SHA-256 6ef7ba3ebba8dab248b6c8570286d887f0c1b34fd554fd7d8916de3f2b599589

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-11y6DY9zmZwnXLc2DQH8cOrHQw324q_ME:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-11y6DY9zmZwnXLc2DQH8cOrHQw324q_ME:reviewed-substantive:033:p4:5

⁹ State v. Martin, No. CM-2024-301 (Wash. Cnty. Dist. Ct.) (July 5, 2024) (Original Information)
¹⁰ 22 O.S. §§ 401–409, supra note 1; OUJI-CR 6-6, supra note 4.
¹¹ 63 O.S. §§ 2-203–2-212, supra note 5 (statutory schedules enumerate specific substances; no listing for “opiods”).
¹² § 504(4), supra note 2; OUJI-CR 6-6, supra note 4.
¹³ § 512, supra note 3.

Exact text SHA-256 cef65acb606d4088d639234704e373ef753913ff9ba2bc8d6b204427c916a07b

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-11y6DY9zmZwnXLc2DQH8cOrHQw324q_ME:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-11y6DY9zmZwnXLc2DQH8cOrHQw324q_ME:reviewed-substantive:033:p5:1

B. Alternative Ground — 22 O.S. § 504(3)

Exact text SHA-256 b932764f03fcdfb6875ac5c34437b001367f6a12a234024dd7a63b4932832865

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-11y6DY9zmZwnXLc2DQH8cOrHQw324q_ME:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-11y6DY9zmZwnXLc2DQH8cOrHQw324q_ME:reviewed-substantive:033:p5:2

In the alternative, the single count purports to charge more than one offense in the disjunctive while pointing to one “said drug.” A single count may not charge multiple offenses.¹⁴ Here, the charging language alternates between “amphetamine” and “opiods”—terms that are not interchangeable in substance or meaning—yet the narrative then collapses those alternatives into a singular referent (“said drug”).¹⁵ If “amphetamine” is intended, it is a specifically enumerated substance under Schedule II.¹⁶ If “opiods” is intended, that term does not appear anywhere in the Uniform Controlled Dangerous Substances Act as a listed identity.¹⁷ Alleging two different controlled substances in the alternative within one count, while referring to a single “said drug,” renders the accusation duplicitous and prevents the charge from identifying one offense with the certainty required for notice and adjudication.¹⁸

Exact text SHA-256 30a39ea5ce0443751f9e9fbcfe1e925f8c913c78bf4634ef1607f851a5ad6802

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-11y6DY9zmZwnXLc2DQH8cOrHQw324q_ME:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-11y6DY9zmZwnXLc2DQH8cOrHQw324q_ME:reviewed-substantive:033:p5:3

IV. CONCLUSION

Exact text SHA-256 cfb4c188199d96bd2e4d15123c8c02e0afa16c5be8bfc677efca44ee133c0b47

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-11y6DY9zmZwnXLc2DQH8cOrHQw324q_ME:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-11y6DY9zmZwnXLc2DQH8cOrHQw324q_ME:reviewed-substantive:033:p5:4

The Original Information is facially inconsistent and fails to identify a single, statutorily recognized controlled substance. Its caption, title, and narrative conflict; the narrative alternates between two different substances while referring to one “said drug”; and the term “OPIODS” is not a listed identity anywhere in Oklahoma’s Uniform Controlled Dangerous Substances Act. Because the identity element is not fixed to one enumerated substance, the Information fails on its face to state a public offense within the meaning of 22 O.S. § 504(4). In the alternative, the

Exact text SHA-256 e874e7dbc23bc0cb7f4ba71baba9d5d3cc22e0575350adb0c396bee07debf84b

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-11y6DY9zmZwnXLc2DQH8cOrHQw324q_ME:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-11y6DY9zmZwnXLc2DQH8cOrHQw324q_ME:reviewed-substantive:033:p5:5

¹⁴ 22 O.S. § 504(3), supra note 5
¹⁵ Original Information (07/05/24), supra note 10 (caption “(AMPHETAMINE/OPIODS)”; title “(AMPHETAMINE)”; narrative “AMPHETAMINE and/or OPIODS, said drug …”).
¹⁶ 63 O.S. § 2-206 (Schedule II list includes amphetamine).
¹⁷ 63 O.S. §§ 2-203–2-212, supra note 5 (no listing for “opiods”).
¹⁸ 22 O.S. §§ 401–409, supra note 1 (charging instrument must state a single offense with certainty sufficient for notice, adjudication, and unanimity).

Exact text SHA-256 e1d6dd402ef2bb1f84c3b7e6de136fb54301ec68602fa36b94578b98fd632f7b

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-11y6DY9zmZwnXLc2DQH8cOrHQw324q_ME:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-11y6DY9zmZwnXLc2DQH8cOrHQw324q_ME:reviewed-substantive:033:p6:1

single count purports to charge more than one offense in the disjunctive. Jurisdiction never vested, and further proceedings may not lawfully continue on this charging paper.

Exact text SHA-256 3e7131f5ba2ff59f31bc6284bfb1921114f801f8abc53e46f565139fe0c1be44

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-11y6DY9zmZwnXLc2DQH8cOrHQw324q_ME:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-11y6DY9zmZwnXLc2DQH8cOrHQw324q_ME:reviewed-substantive:033:p6:2

V. PRAYER FOR RELIEF

Exact text SHA-256 62191241e3e930f3a534c9a9e722c9527a6211b6cc1fed0856b99fea5f13fcde

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-11y6DY9zmZwnXLc2DQH8cOrHQw324q_ME:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-11y6DY9zmZwnXLc2DQH8cOrHQw324q_ME:reviewed-substantive:033:p6:3

WHEREFORE, Defendant respectfully prays that the Court enter an order as follows:

Exact text SHA-256 239b16ba430165f778fe18141eca6e6afaa9a27be2dbd3a02d7fd656b7452ed5

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-11y6DY9zmZwnXLc2DQH8cOrHQw324q_ME:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-11y6DY9zmZwnXLc2DQH8cOrHQw324q_ME:reviewed-substantive:033:p6:4

1. Sustain this demurrer pursuant to 22 O.S. § 504(4), and in the alternative under 22 O.S. § 504(3);

Exact text SHA-256 046e6b76e74d4dfc84fa623c1288f270d3e1c91853b7ff02d3e91206216c74e4

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-11y6DY9zmZwnXLc2DQH8cOrHQw324q_ME:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-11y6DY9zmZwnXLc2DQH8cOrHQw324q_ME:reviewed-substantive:033:p6:5

2. Declare the Original Information (07/05/24) invalid and non-operative;

Exact text SHA-256 88e8588bcb94e84a229f0f4f0d0505d2986490cfb72f33b76b8948ff9b497f98

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-11y6DY9zmZwnXLc2DQH8cOrHQw324q_ME:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-11y6DY9zmZwnXLc2DQH8cOrHQw324q_ME:reviewed-substantive:033:p6:6

3. Dismiss this prosecution without leave to refile pursuant to 22 O.S. § 508; or, alternatively, dismiss without leave to amend in this cause and direct that any further prosecution, if any, be initiated only by a new information that complies with law;

Exact text SHA-256 9ae2fd851e6ad82f0676b2049993d7d8c60d100fe420c633dbfc35b6f140edf3

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-11y6DY9zmZwnXLc2DQH8cOrHQw324q_ME:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-11y6DY9zmZwnXLc2DQH8cOrHQw324q_ME:reviewed-substantive:033:p6:7

4. If the Court does not direct further prosecution, order that Defendant be discharged (if in custody), any bond be exonerated, any cash deposit be refunded, and all derivative process—including any outstanding bench warrant and associated forfeiture—be vacated and recalled, pursuant to 22 O.S. § 509; and

Exact text SHA-256 e16b4fee48a9b3140f318d7454fbda9b0304a2d9c0695532ac0c5ea4de69d525

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-11y6DY9zmZwnXLc2DQH8cOrHQw324q_ME:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-11y6DY9zmZwnXLc2DQH8cOrHQw324q_ME:reviewed-substantive:033:p6:8

5. Grant such other and further relief as justice requires.

Exact text SHA-256 6d397eceebd7bbee539514e0181c8a4a5559223583123f8102f62bc50737a2df