The Oklahoma Fugitive

Record archive

DEFENDANT'S OBJECTION TO FIRST AMENDED INFORMATION (FROM PRO-SE DEFENDANT) (COPY PUT IN JUDGE AND DA'S BOX)

Source-owning proceeding: CM-2024-00301 · Existing document identity: DOC-1085675353

Existing contextual aliases: D46. Aliases do not establish provenance.

View original PDF Download unchanged original

Unmodified, unredacted retained PDF; 14 physical page/image position(s), 586021 bytes.

Original and shipped SHA-256 3d6a584d2eac2486a23e984c19581fcf011dc9eb6c69ef98028a3c845b3fd0ab

Separate docket appearances

A docket entry is distinct from the source-owned original document. Cross-proceeding entries link to this single original; no second authoritative copy is created.

CM-2024-00301 · ROW-075 · entry date as printed: 07/31/2025

Existing text coverage and recorded date roles

Only the listed existing permitted passages are searchable. Original images/PDFs and existing omissions remain unchanged; no OCR or inferred complete text. Representations remain separate and passages retain their existing source order/locators. No inferred continuous page transcription.

Inherited transcription/review notes describe prior source review, including any wording such as “this session”; no new transcription was performed for this export.

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033

Selected existing passages

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p1:1

OBJECTION TO AMENDED INFORMATION

Exact text SHA-256 55457bd58f62c4983c21da3bd3a677bcf035234d8272567491e7fa654fee3799

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p1:2

COMES NOW the Defendant, Flynn Robert Martin, appearing pro se, ¹ and respectfully objects to the “INFORMATION (1st Amended as to correct name of Controlled Dangerous Substance),” filed December 31, 2024, on the ground that it was filed in violation of the mandatory post-plea requirements of 22 O.S. § 304, resulting in material prejudice to the rights of the Defendant and rendering the filing void ab initio.

Exact text SHA-256 4f470fb17231a63abcb5a00e2100dda27fe65e08b0ef89ac3eae75fbfa87554e

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p1:3

¹ Defendant files this Objection subject to, and without waiving, the pending Defendant’s Motion to Disqualify the Honorable Judge Jared Sigler, filed May 14, 2025. See State v. Martin, No. CM-2024-301 (Wash. Cnty. Dist. Ct. May 14, 2025) (Def.’s Mot. to Disqualify) (Doc. #1084975032). Defendant has previously stated on the record that no further court appearances will be made until that motion is sustained or stands overruled of record. See id. (Def.’s Obj. to Further Proceedings & Req. for Immediate Ruling on the Papers) (Doc. #1085057485) (filed May 23, 2025).

Exact text SHA-256 73125ee9d0590dafa88b6dc87b50e3ed5bca431eb72f77cb3dbe3c72bc6e7a51

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p2:1

I. INTRODUCTION

Exact text SHA-256 511b20a4e6b07129dc8c2af532c53daaf6d78e8a75652bd60b8dae23cb7288b7

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p2:2

This Objection challenges the procedural and legal validity of the “INFORMATION (1st Amended as to correct name of Controlled Dangerous Substance)” filed on December 31, 2024 (hereafter, Amended Information). By styling the pleading as a “correction,” the State implicitly abandoned the original charge while substituting a materially different substance—an essential element of the offense under 63 O.S. § 2-402(A).

Exact text SHA-256 ab84927af6d4f9fb72f35abda8a49b1933813d47a541d0080d151cd66b46f616

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p2:3

Under 22 O.S. § 304, a post-plea amendment may take effect only (1) on order of the court and (2) after the court finds the change can be made without material prejudice to the defendant. The State failed to satisfy either requirement. Because no order authorized the amendment and no non-prejudice finding was made, the Amended Information is void ab initio and cannot support further proceedings.

Exact text SHA-256 fa35c3ebab11be4b0778164072a3010f822deca35a07093d4ea15581da7f6fc5

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p2:4

The pleading is doubly void because it charges possession of “tetrahydrocannabinolis [sic]”, a term absent from every controlled-substance schedule in Oklahoma law. An Information that alleges a substance not defined by statute fails to state a public offense and confers no jurisdiction. ²

Exact text SHA-256 1e2649c066648044b1e08cd71b12f1e3fee2bd6d7b6e7501e678ec8392ee81d5

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p2:5

Having abandoned the original theory and failed to perfect the substitute, the prosecution has left the record without a single operative Information. The resulting notice vacuum violates both Oklahoma’s pleading code (22 O.S. §§ 402(3), 409(6)–(7)) and the due-process guarantee articulated in Parker v. State. ³ More than a year after arraignment, Defendant remains bound over for trial without a valid charge to answer—structural prejudice that requires the Amended Information be stricken and this prosecution brought into statutory compliance, if it is to proceed at all.

Exact text SHA-256 3d48dba3e0c1a88de78a12afb681a5cf37ba6c5d67b9c9a32163a0ce839ffd17

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p2:6

² Potts v. State, 72 Okla. Crim. 91, 113 P.2d 839, 842–43 (1941).
³ Parker v. State, 1996 OK CR 19, ¶¶ 18–19, 917 P.2d 980, 987–88 (Okla. Crim. App. 1996).

Exact text SHA-256 705d0882d95954ce3ce6a05ce7c865f0de70f7770ac610c2b75df657936163c1

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p3:1

II. CHRONOLOGY OF RELEVANT EVENTS

Exact text SHA-256 9b0a132dec05e5c6a6f6b044dc4c27eb8210feeff0129a5ccaf97711e04f57fe

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p3:2

On July 5, 2024, the State filed the original “INFORMATION,” initiating this prosecution with a single-count misdemeanor charge under 63 O.S. § 2-402. That charging document (hereinafter, the Original Information) remained the operative pleading at the time of Defendant’s arraignment on July 8, 2024, where he entered a plea of not guilty.

Exact text SHA-256 d37b8149a6e1130d3c0c39124ba28921c2f9294ec2b65f81cec7d971d73c811a

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p3:3

On December 31, 2024, the State filed the Amended Information. That post-plea filing has never been acknowledged by judicial order and forms the subject of the present Objection.

Exact text SHA-256 297d384b0ba9715571d12385e159535d28a598f3782c6ca3a4a9309f30072c5f

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p3:4

On January 10, 2025—the final day for trial readiness filings—then-defense counsel filed a Motion to Dismiss ⁴ referencing a substance and statutory schedule not clearly identified in either the Original or Amended Information. That same day, the court struck the previously scheduled jury trial. As of the date of this filing, more than six months later, no new jury setting has been entered.

Exact text SHA-256 b877208f9b5e791993eb23c603860e7d13e13dd24541b27fdb5f491c717b6a01

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p3:5

III. STATUTORY FRAMEWORK

Exact text SHA-256 57fbb3a4845ce68b406a00a4510fddd35d99df8114a84b0c50c62975ac826e3d

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p3:6

A. Mandatory Judicial Prerequisites for Post-Plea Amendments Under 22 O.S. § 304

Exact text SHA-256 e5cc6a1fd31f69dde8126b72902f35a6667ef7e9fff56d48d87a67fc430424e9

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p3:7

Oklahoma law strictly limits the State’s ability to amend an Information once the defendant has entered a plea. Title 22 O.S. § 304 provides:

Exact text SHA-256 60c36116b3922be3f5fe4233fe9ea351a164763720c9db4087def3806b34721b

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p3:8

“An information may be amended in matter of substance or form at any time before the defendant pleads, without leave, and may be amended after plea on order of the court where the same can be done without material prejudice to the right of the defendant; no amendment shall cause any delay of the trial, unless for good cause shown by affidavit.”

Exact text SHA-256 3fe12e960254519d9c93c8bf5a8914b32ac9cd3330d6e38370683b2cd01b0bd6

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p3:9

⁴ State v. Martin, No. CM-2024-301 (Wash. Cnty. Dist. Ct. Jan. 10, 2025) (Def.’s Mot. to Dismiss) (Doc. #1083872865)

Exact text SHA-256 602d680255709e07e3fd52ca469c48ea1decd9418cdb9ee1252d52c81fc62a6b

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p4:1

By its plain terms, § 304 distinguishes between pre-plea and post-plea amendments. Before plea, the State may amend without leave of court. But once a plea has been entered, the statute imposes two mandatory and jurisdictional prerequisites: (1) A court order authorizing the amendment; and (2) A judicial determination that the amendment will not materially prejudice the rights of the defendant. ⁵

Exact text SHA-256 49dfe96a329fe03e32cdefd9a8333bc7a14374f6234c00c0938dd899137971c3

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p4:2

These two conditions operate in tandem. The court’s order is the legal manifestation of its finding that the proposed change will not materially impair the defendant’s ability to prepare or present a defense. Without both, the State is without power to alter its charging theory post-plea, and the district court lacks authority to proceed on the amended pleading.

Exact text SHA-256 8916edd3972bf37bc134fee24389be196050af8554d82c98bea7f1c4cc339799

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p4:3

These requirements are jurisdictional safeguards. They protect the defendant’s settled reliance on the charging theory as it existed at the time of plea and guard against unfair tactical shifts by the prosecution. When the State files an amended Information after plea without first obtaining the required order and non-prejudice determination, the amendment is void ab initio, incapable of vesting jurisdiction or supporting adjudication. The statutory text admits no exceptions, implied compliance, or retroactive validation.

Exact text SHA-256 5dbfc57993b10ef0fc51ec67fb309a68eaf081fd8a0d1896643ed54155d3b57d

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p4:4

B. Change to the Named Substance Is a Substantive Amendment Within the Meaning of § 304

Exact text SHA-256 953c793586a2ff8c9d361e869d247800363e745e3730c9d8c99f20ae49cd4b0d

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p4:5

The State titled its December 31, 2024 filing as a “First Amended Information as to correct name of Controlled Dangerous Substance.” By its own caption, the State concedes that the amendment altered the identity of the alleged substance forming the basis of prosecution.

Exact text SHA-256 68a961ba137ef0d9462f2d944608c21992c2ec8bd8472f83bd5eb210bd0e903a

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p4:6

⁵ Johnson v. State, 97 Okla. Crim. 52, 257 P.2d 841, 843 (Okla. Crim. App. 1953) (post-plea amendment valid only if “on order of the court” and “without material prejudice”).

Exact text SHA-256 1bc565633e55ecfb0cdc01da113e724f43ba6c13afc2426c1f569f7b22062b12

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p5:1

Under Oklahoma law, this change is material. Title 63 O.S. § 2-402(A)(1) prohibits possession of a “controlled dangerous substance” as defined by statute. The identity of the specific substance is therefore essential to the completion of the offense. It defines not only the prohibited conduct, but also the applicable schedule and statutory classification.

Exact text SHA-256 2ed5658e531cfbdc2abe70e01d6f309f3927a85b77c4813cf8cb2559a771be56

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p5:2

This interpretation is confirmed by Oklahoma’s uniform jury instructions, which require the State to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant knowingly possessed “the controlled dangerous substance of [Name of Substance].” ⁶ The bracketed instruction compels the State to specify the exact substance alleged and confirms that substance identity is a verdict-controlling element.

Exact text SHA-256 12f5ff9a15da48a60d80a048d2054464408f2fbc1866d4b86e44b26e8e8288f4

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p5:3

Accordingly, where the State amends its pleading for the stated purpose of correcting the name of the controlled substance, it is necessarily making a substantive post-plea change to the charging theory. That type of amendment triggers the mandatory procedural requirements of 22 O.S. § 304 and cannot take legal effect without judicial approval.

Exact text SHA-256 4628329e818b083d77c990dc60a718055cdf757a574fe2fd7537c734cf1d8103

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p5:4

C. Statutory and Constitutional Baselines for Charging Clarity and Notice

Exact text SHA-256 efd3a63c9ce58104b1b227362fa647206f95f215a1a58ce66effaffbdcc0f2c7

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p5:5

Oklahoma law requires that a criminal Information clearly articulate the offense alleged so that a defendant may understand the charge and prepare a defense. This notice obligation arises under both the United States and Oklahoma Constitutions. ⁷

Exact text SHA-256 6194e92878564401d90a16686f9ad92701cdf0fd711b5647a1e0eda80ca72160

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p5:6

To implement this constitutional guarantee, Oklahoma’s pleading code imposes specific requirements for the sufficiency of an Information. The code requires that an information be “direct and certain as to the particular circumstances of the offense… necessary to constitute a

Exact text SHA-256 31178047af625846bdb2a8855ab8a3ea3ea21dde91dc868abca84512ac09559a

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p5:7

⁶ Instruction No. 6-6, OUJI-CR(2d) (DRUG OFFENSES: POSSESSION - ELEMENTS).
The instruction’s bracketed element obliges the State to name the specific substance as part of its prima facie case.
⁷ U.S. Const. amends. VI, XIV; Okla. Const. art. II, §§ 7, 20; Parker v. State, 1996 OK CR 19, ¶¶ 18–19, 917 P.2d 980, 987–88 (Okla. Crim. App. 1996).

Exact text SHA-256 2c9afa44206dfa68e4c34c9d7f1d83854bbd451fc7f0901ca120735e09e21ee8

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p6:1

complete offense,” and that the charge be pled with enough clarity “to enable a person of common understanding to know what is intended” and with “such a degree of certainty as to enable the court to pronounce judgment upon a conviction.” ⁸

Exact text SHA-256 2fc3eae58806173594880a0b5e910cf06aa94f3e51d39ebe30108f05dd00b680

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p6:2

These statutes are designed to ensure that the charging document both (1) identifies a public offense as defined by law and (2) does so with sufficient clarity to provide meaningful notice to the accused. Stability in the charging theory is an essential feature of that framework. Where conflicting Informations appear in the record—particularly where they allege distinct substances or statutory classifications—questions arise as to whether the defendant has received the type of singular, definite notice required by law.

Exact text SHA-256 227b91a36d82ffc872c982475462adaa8d58a03e7e6b5efa63fd0244a17252ee

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p6:3

In addition, the charging document must allege a substance or act that is actually prohibited by Oklahoma law. Where the named controlled dangerous substance does not correspond to any entry in the schedules defined by Title 63, the Information may fail to state a public offense under Oklahoma law.

Exact text SHA-256 81b3d3672aae485f1c0bd16ff54a655de5e6170a76d604629030b658dea36c35

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p6:4

IV. THE AMENDED INFORMATION IS VOID AB INITIO

Exact text SHA-256 50ed5ca04cc4c18ee4e323a1ef1cd76928aa394daca6301a5012a3ab6ced88d4

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p6:5

A. Filed Without the Order and Non-Prejudice Finding Required by 22 O.S. § 304

Exact text SHA-256 8e2a6ba1779a855da36acfce8c4748926c46db91a21612bf62e8152bed9acde1

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p6:6

The record contains no court order authorizing the State’s December 31, 2024 amendment, nor any corresponding finding that the change could be made without material prejudice to the defendant. These omissions are jurisdictional failures.

Exact text SHA-256 c6c61bb743c272eabe7a08efc494e1f71f93b7849f9d52088dabc6bbde26ae00

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p6:7

⁸ Okla. Stat. tit. 22, § 402(3) (2024): “The indictment or information must be direct and certain as it regards… (3) The particular circumstances of the offense charged, when they are necessary to constitute a complete offense.”
Okla. Stat. tit. 22, § 409(6)–(7) (2024): “The indictment or information is sufficient if it can be understood therefrom: (6) That the act or omission charged as the offense is clearly and distinctly set forth in ordinary and concise language, without repetition, and in such a manner as to enable a person of common understanding to know what is intended; (7) That the act or omission charged as the offense is stated with such a degree of certainty, as to enable the court to pronounce judgment upon a conviction according to the right of the case.”

Exact text SHA-256 b9a4d7a9bf9ac10b97bd44a8b068568ac4def59c5c3dad6f230bf6686d369978

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p7:1

Once a plea has been entered, a charging amendment may take effect only after the court affirmatively determines that the change will not prejudice the defendant and memorializes that determination in an order. In the absence of either act, jurisdiction to proceed under the amended pleading never vests.

Exact text SHA-256 b7892323b59712128ccc89b66cb241075d692e0ca6a7797ba5bc71427219216d

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p7:2

No such order appears in the docket, and no minute entry reflects any judicial determination regarding prejudice. The amendment was thus filed outside the statutory framework and never acquired legal force. Oklahoma law does not permit post-plea amendments to bypass § 304’s gatekeeping function and operate by inference or silent acquiescence.

Exact text SHA-256 0046cd44e83eff800d1fd7c4a0407f25a743c68c76ca20bd7f8055359ec891f7

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p7:3

Accordingly, the Amended Information is void ab initio. It confers no jurisdiction, is not subject to nunc pro tunc validation, and cannot serve as the operative charging instrument in these proceedings.

Exact text SHA-256 a481040ee62bee301916597e31da2b4adb68ce8c3e54be354ffce99acced3606

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p7:4

B. Fails to State a Public Offense

Exact text SHA-256 29a51fc20fea00b55c23d90e2b8c7402da8adad1ed4d6e1648aef1634c08685e

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p7:5

The Amended Information alleges possession of “tetrahydrocannabinolis,” labeling it a Schedule II substance. The term appears nowhere in Oklahoma’s controlled-substance schedules, which are exhaustively set out in 63 O.S. §§ 2-204 – 2-212. Because the alleged substance is not listed or otherwise defined by statute, the pleading omits a material element of the offense described in 63 O.S. § 2-402—namely, that the item possessed be a “controlled dangerous substance.”

Exact text SHA-256 9d90cad0f31a111f32cc4b3e21ded8db5e951a0b6d7648806e03477de33acb8c

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p7:6

An Information that fails to allege a statutorily defined crime does not confer subject-matter jurisdiction. ⁹ The defect is facial and incurable: a court cannot supply a missing statutory element by inference, and the State cannot prosecute conduct that the Legislature has not criminalized.

Exact text SHA-256 d5ea26d7cbe33c7cd1ce7b8d58e6204b25813b9c58333709a5ffb1799555d689

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p7:7

⁹ Potts v. State, 72 Okla. Crim. 91, 113 P.2d 839, 842–43 (Okla. Crim. App. 1941); Parker v. State, 1996 OK CR 19, 19, 917 P.2d 980, 987 (Okla. Crim. App. 1996); Kelley v. State, 31 Okla. Crim. 51, 236 P. 915, 917–18 (Okla. Crim. App. 1925) (information omitting statutory element “fails to state a public offense” → dismissal).

Exact text SHA-256 18ad9d629b495ccbe5eef76e1d7f9f85b5906198edf907919835d90e4c8ccd3f

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p8:1

Accordingly, the Amended Information is independently void ab initio for failure to state a public offense.

Exact text SHA-256 2e93fb3a48d78d6cd208a1c8ec2d4e065c6b33b53292c17c0e6750035fae7fba

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p8:2

V. RESULTING MATERIAL PREJUDICE

Exact text SHA-256 df2cfd7e5476409ebba491259d5109091694ac82cefa0986a98de8a839560f42

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p8:3

A. Presumptive Prejudice When § 304 Safeguards Are Bypassed

Exact text SHA-256 cb4d0915bfbe4420d38af94e2b545fdb4c40bf3f103b7b8280e872f3d8196587

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p8:4

Under 22 O.S. § 304, a post-plea amendment to the Information is prohibited absent a prior judicial determination that the change can be made “without material prejudice to the right of the defendant.” The statute does not authorize post-plea amendment by default or waiver. It establishes a precondition: unless and until the court finds no material prejudice, no amendment may be made. This finding is a jurisdictional prerequisite to altering the charging theory after plea.

Exact text SHA-256 8245e0bc7418804e57c7045d615832ee6bf3e3b33f8f0b12d69a40edaec2c70c

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p8:5

Where no such determination appears in the record—as is the case here—prejudice is presumed by operation of law. The defense, having already pleaded and begun trial preparation under the original charge, is legally entitled to rely on the stability of that charging theory. A silent, unilateral change introduced outside statutory procedure necessarily impairs those reliance interests and triggers the very prejudice § 304 is designed to prevent. The failure to obtain a judicial finding of non-prejudice renders the amendment legally defective, and the prejudice it occasioned is not subject to rebuttal or retroactive cure.

Exact text SHA-256 7b245d868ec4b1466bc2aed939db3069b6be0f1ecf2da54af6bb4fbceff9da4e

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p8:6

B. The State Abandoned the Original Information Without Lawfully Perfecting Its Substitute

Exact text SHA-256 b2130ea64274aca2c7aba72097f68df4c79319f965cf8c952aef7fc20f2d0dc7

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p8:7

By captioning the December 31, 2024 filing as an “Amended Information as to correct name of Controlled Dangerous Substance,” the State effectively disclaimed the charging theory advanced

Exact text SHA-256 4d5e5112f02b0fa6124d401826379765b509468a140f9f455134f1b2f72f6ab7

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p9:1

in the Original Information. That act of correction—on its face—abandoned the original substance allegation and announced the State’s intent to proceed on a materially different factual and statutory bases.

Exact text SHA-256 04f6c7730dc08c7f3a30dff215ba5e91095b0d099d6ca51b23d0768485b6fd02

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p9:2

However, because the Amended Information was filed unilaterally—without a court order predicated upon a judicial finding of non-prejudice—it never acquired legal force. The State did not comply with 22 O.S. § 304, nor did it seek or obtain any ruling recognizing the amended charge. No minute entry reflects that the court has acknowledged the amendment; no order has been entered adopting it as controlling. Yet the State has never attempted to reinstate or clarify the original theory, either.

Exact text SHA-256 a1c15417693b061ee35c6f28151e4fd5182af3195207363d80e48b671cf06cc7

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p9:3

As a result, the case now proceeds without a valid charging instrument. The Original Information has been functionally abandoned. The Amended Information is void ab initio. What remains is a procedural vacuum—no operative theory of prosecution, no clear statutory basis, and no authoritative notice of the crime alleged. This is a structural failure that prejudices the Defendant at every turn and deprives the Court of jurisdiction to proceed.

Exact text SHA-256 5e9024edb95219cba2bfa0774d461ea17429cb194043053e2830d8f781350f91

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p9:4

C. Failure to Rearraign After a Substantive Amendment Deprived Defendant of Notice and Judicial Probable-Cause Review

Exact text SHA-256 621af17c36dc27e8896d3f1e16fac6c6178e31c6f23f6d3a41e36387e20c3a3c

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p9:5

The December 31, 2024 “Amended Information as to correct name of Controlled Dangerous Substance” represents a facially substantive change in the State’s charging theory. By its own caption, the amendment displaces the controlled substance alleged in the Original Information and introduces a materially different allegation. Under Oklahoma law, such a change is not ministerial—it is substantive, and it triggers renewed procedural safeguards.

Exact text SHA-256 d073095855de4ec732b5ff78700b0954e574eda86bedfa0c88987aa3643da204

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p10:1

Chief among these is rearraignment. When the State alters a material element of the offense after plea, it must obtain leave of court under 22 O.S. § 304 and present the amended charge for judicial acknowledgment. At that point, the defendant must be formally rearraigned pursuant to 22 O.S. §§ 451–453. This ensures two essential protections: (1) that the amended charge rests on a judicial finding of probable cause, and (2) that the defendant is given clear notice of the new accusation and an opportunity to respond. ¹⁰

Exact text SHA-256 a784bb7c01a4537afedd33fae35d9268bd1a4a0cefab396967795ad732e5cee5

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p10:2

Neither safeguard occurred here. The State unilaterally filed the Amended Information without seeking leave of court and without a finding that the change would not result in material prejudice. Because the procedural prerequisites were bypassed, no rearraignment followed. Defendant was never informed in open court of the amended charge, never asked to plead, and never afforded a forum to challenge probable cause under the altered theory.

Exact text SHA-256 14aef6fafa5c9fdc3910fc4f83a2c36b5b1d802c19b0e7149208580a1ca7b4ab

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p10:3

Compounding this deprivation is the unexplained timing of the amendment itself. After nearly six months of pretrial proceedings based on the Original Information—including multiple court appearances and the setting of a jury trial—the State abruptly altered the substance of the charge without explanation. The record contains no motion, no affidavit, and no statement from the prosecution identifying the basis for the change or the factual predicate supporting it.

Exact text SHA-256 ec562b9ea71bc607de42d620fb68f10871cc8f907ffda1bc42ddb647f23dddef

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p10:4

As a result, Defendant remains bound over for trial more than six months after the amendment was filed, yet he has never been called to answer to the new charge or advised of the State’s underlying theory. The failure to re-arraign is a structural failure of notice, rooted in the State’s decision to abandon its original theory without lawfully perfecting the substitute. This omission further confirms that the Amended Information is void and that no valid charge presently exists before the Court.

Exact text SHA-256 c1e41ce148a1c34475e02add6e3097c7e006b89c846de6ce2edf7ff0ceac4ffa

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p10:5

¹⁰ Shiever v. State, 94 Okla. Crim. 279, 234 P.2d 921, 923 (Okla. Crim. App. 1951); Trent v. State, 66 Okla. Crim. 302, 91 P.2d 790 (Okla. Crim. App. 1939); Parker v. State, 1954 OK CR 78, 11, 273 P.2d 778, 780 (Okla. Crim. App. 1954) (substantive post-plea amendment requires rearraignment and time to plead).

Exact text SHA-256 189dd5f2499a73b46333462f6d8c6ec39a63e8024e26379e2bbce3f21c88f267

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p11:1

D. State’s Written Response Adds a New Substance and Cites an Inapplicable Schedule

Exact text SHA-256 97b8eb10ccdba58f574ead3664faf877c5ca384cde5f1b2aa4fd3b893586f7aa

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p11:2

On February 26, 2025, the State filed a written brief. ¹¹ In that filing, the State repeatedly referred to a substance identified as “tetrahydrocannibols”—a term not alleged in either the Original or Amended Information and not listed in any schedule of controlled substances under Oklahoma law.

Exact text SHA-256 748cbce85d44914bd9e3141d87395d5975ffe85ebafe1fe57ac37740d85bb98d

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p11:3

To support this newly asserted term, the State cited and quoted 63 O.S. § 2-208, which enumerates Schedule III substances. This contradicts both the Original Information and the Amended Information, each of which alleges possession of a substance identified as Schedule II on its face.

Exact text SHA-256 fa40dad8ca181ecd261f0e1723b554e3e56329ad68bce227260e46fc12025fd0

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p11:4

The State has now advanced at least three separate substance names across the course of these proceedings, invoking two legally distinct schedules, without reconciling or explaining the discrepancies. No amended Information has been filed to align the charging instrument with the arguments presented in the State’s brief, and no court order has ever clarified which version of the charge controls.

Exact text SHA-256 6880327285f31422341c14a0dddfd7c08f11947fbb12711f592ee50a3b14fdc7

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p11:5

This inconsistency confirms that the statutory basis for the prosecution remains undefined. The introduction of an additional unscheduled substance with a contradictory legal framework cited in support thereof, further undermines charging clarity and reinforces that Defendant has been given no stable notice of the offense alleged.

Exact text SHA-256 cef92bd27f72e6e567206c06b5228f81c6b838995911c6f70a56d500036616b6

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p11:6

¹¹ State v. Martin, No. CM-2024-301 (Wash. Cnty. Dist. Ct. Feb. 26, 2025) (State’s Resp. to Mot. to Dismiss) (Doc. #1084269717)

Exact text SHA-256 9f20e86f407be7af8c12f67705b3fd76344d590ec1315b1fa08ec3ff0ba4ef6a

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p12:1

E. Prejudice Is Structural and Irremediable

Exact text SHA-256 6ae6e7c39eb248ed4b857a74e78e580593851004c9ac0a410b92065b6aad1f0d

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p12:2

The defects identified above collapse the very framework necessary for any criminal prosecution to validly proceed. Without an operative Information—given the abandoned original, the unperfected and unauthorized amendment, and a subsequent brief introducing yet another inconsistent substance—the Defendant has remained bound by conditions of release, repeatedly compelled to appear before the Court, and threatened with sanctions, all while lacking the single, constitutionally mandated element of due process: a clear, lawful, and stable charge to answer.

Exact text SHA-256 1dca7ac20fbe1be664d2b1a94d83bde8737b5819b8a6473b59320c6bd5dfd01d

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p12:3

No curative measure at this juncture can restore the time, resources, and strategic preparation irretrievably lost due to the shifting and invalid allegations advanced by the State. The prejudice suffered is structural, permeating the entire proceeding and fundamentally undermining the fairness and integrity of the process itself. The prosecution, by disregarding the mandatory safeguards of 22 O.S. § 304, has forfeited its jurisdictional foundation. To now overlook such fundamental failures would irreparably compromise the constitutional rights afforded to the Defendant and damage the integrity of the criminal justice system itself. The prejudice inflicted is not merely substantial—it is irreparable. The only appropriate and proportionate remedy under these exceptional circumstances is dismissal.

Exact text SHA-256 30902309392ac697b56a31fc7f98787cdcb6b9472469ad663436628fdd58e8b7

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p13:1

VI. PRAYER FOR RELIEF

Exact text SHA-256 a4bed4a422c47fc136d72a007a56572775e802693699b03eafe72edd3505d238

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p13:2

WHEREFORE, Defendant Flynn Robert Martin respectfully requests that this Court enter an Order:

Exact text SHA-256 cf2d9c6c689bdd7cc2fdae96818f6714ac6fb45b803bbb5872f3c6f25b4de051

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p13:3

1. Declaring the “INFORMATION (1st Amended as to correct name of Controlled Dangerous Substance),” filed December 31, 2024, void ab initio for failure to comply with the mandatory requirements of 22 O.S. § 304 and for failing on its face to state a public offense;

Exact text SHA-256 e9657960a04016ae5713533b43f73b87846a0d0af5607f6d893ed13c1cbbe74c

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p13:4

2. Striking the void Amended Information from the record in its entirety;

Exact text SHA-256 c5cfabe5d1a132f6f9c58cbe98f4dfbff4e485b9c2aae8f6f81b830cb49570f1

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p13:5

3. Dismissing this prosecution, due to the structural and irremediable prejudice caused by the State’s procedural and jurisdictional failures, or, in the alternative, strictly limiting any further prosecution to the Original Information filed on July 5, 2024, unless and until the State fully and properly complies with the statutory requirements of 22 O.S. § 304; and

Exact text SHA-256 df1f7470d79d1a08bef879fad0f715b7ea075f9fe3d5ff7f26e78670177ed508

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p13:6

4. Granting such other and further relief as the Court deems just, equitable, and necessary under the circumstances.

Exact text SHA-256 3664434db20579044e71e46a53a5ce5bb8e4814f09680ac4bd21fcaf72fb7332

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p14:1

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

Exact text SHA-256 3dc19f7617308076d8a0c8c58aee55aacb18e38102b852c1a51925819f27503f

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-1WyCmy1mqOvf7rJhwUWkoAVmFVRd2oE3c:reviewed-substantive:033:p14:2

I hereby certify that on this 25th day of July, 2025, a true and correct copy of the foregoing Objection to First Amended Information was mailed to the Washington County Court Clerk with a request that, upon filing, a copy be placed in the mailbox of the Washington County District Attorney at the courthouse.

Exact text SHA-256 69b6327cc1666f3ae791796975dbe92ef58a0c0fb64631b15c42e69d56a17568