The Oklahoma Fugitive

Record archive

DEFENDANT'S MOTION TO DISQUALIFY THE HONORABLE JUDGE JARED SIGLER (COPY PUT IN JUDGE AND DA'S BOX)

Source-owning proceeding: CM-2024-00301 · Existing document identity: DOC-1084975032

Existing contextual aliases: D25. Aliases do not establish provenance.

View original PDF Download unchanged original

Unmodified, unredacted retained PDF; 16 physical page/image position(s), 689337 bytes.

Original and shipped SHA-256 2845519f7bfbff9ef20985683981e97b9e218042461df2e1d9afaacebdd85230

Separate docket appearances

A docket entry is distinct from the source-owned original document. Cross-proceeding entries link to this single original; no second authoritative copy is created.

CM-2024-00301 · ROW-051 · entry date as printed: 05/14/2025

Existing text coverage and recorded date roles

Only the listed existing permitted passages are searchable. Original images/PDFs and existing omissions remain unchanged; no OCR or inferred complete text. Representations remain separate and passages retain their existing source order/locators. No inferred continuous page transcription.

Inherited transcription/review notes describe prior source review, including any wording such as “this session”; no new transcription was performed for this export.

record:ASSET-DRIVE-15WOhPAK2RuQDNJqWOAA41hxJ4mw8g3Eb
record:ASSET-DRIVE-15WOhPAK2RuQDNJqWOAA41hxJ4mw8g3Eb:substantive-completion:033

Selected existing passages

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-15WOhPAK2RuQDNJqWOAA41hxJ4mw8g3Eb
record:ASSET-DRIVE-15WOhPAK2RuQDNJqWOAA41hxJ4mw8g3Eb:excerpt:appearance

COMES NOW the Defendant, Flynn Robert Martin, acting Pro Se, and respectfully moves this
Court for the disqualification and recusal of the Honorable Judge Jared Sigler from presiding
over the above-captioned matter. Defendant asserts this motion exclusively on grounds of the
appearance of impartiality, as governed by Rule 2.11(A) of the Oklahoma Code of Judicial
Conduct¹ and further supported by 20 O.S. § 1401(E).² Defendant expressly states that this
motion does not allege actual bias, prejudice, or wrongdoing by the Court, but rather addresses
circumstances under which the Court’s impartiality might reasonably be questioned by a fully
informed and reasonable observer.

Exact text SHA-256 f0a8dc56eceda134c04d1083e6a60acf639129c95ce0515016d917355ad2d118

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-15WOhPAK2RuQDNJqWOAA41hxJ4mw8g3Eb
record:ASSET-DRIVE-15WOhPAK2RuQDNJqWOAA41hxJ4mw8g3Eb:excerpt:restriction-asserted

Pursuant to Rule 15(d) of the Rules for District Courts,⁵ Defendant further notes that once this
motion has been formally submitted and filed with the Court Clerk, the Honorable Judge Sigler
may not proceed further in this matter until this motion for disqualification is resolved on the
record.

Exact text SHA-256 668bc973bc79eb315870b5db4659140c54273f2d026d084b7118f0dfc008a92a

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-15WOhPAK2RuQDNJqWOAA41hxJ4mw8g3Eb:substantive-completion:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-15WOhPAK2RuQDNJqWOAA41hxJ4mw8g3Eb:substantive-completion:033:title

DEFENDANT’S MOTION TO DISQUALIFY THE HONORABLE JUDGE JARED SIGLER
I. INTRODUCTION

Exact text SHA-256 9ec21856b92426546702e447a66f57625dad51d39545ae8a76550eb7d9785756

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-15WOhPAK2RuQDNJqWOAA41hxJ4mw8g3Eb:substantive-completion:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-15WOhPAK2RuQDNJqWOAA41hxJ4mw8g3Eb:substantive-completion:033:procedural-introduction

In strict compliance with the procedural prerequisites outlined in Rule 15(a) of the Rules for District Courts,³ Defendant previously submitted a sealed, in-camera request seeking Judge Sigler’s voluntary recusal. USPS tracking confirms that this sealed request was delivered to the Washington County Courthouse on May 8, 2025. As of May 13, 2025, no docket entry or response to that sealed request has been entered into the official record. Because no trial date has currently been scheduled in this matter—only a pre-trial hearing is pending—this motion to disqualify is procedurally timely and fully compliant with Rule 15(a), which provides that *“not less than ten (10) days before the case is set for trial a motion to disqualify a judge or to transfer a cause to another judge may be filed and a copy delivered to the judge.”⁴

Exact text SHA-256 44398a6eb96c23f8bb8d9c0ae37d351d7a3b91af75021f5dca51858481254d1d

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-15WOhPAK2RuQDNJqWOAA41hxJ4mw8g3Eb:substantive-completion:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-15WOhPAK2RuQDNJqWOAA41hxJ4mw8g3Eb:substantive-completion:033:accompanying-material-request

Defendant respectfully submits the accompanying affidavit in support of this motion, including the attached procedural timeline (Exhibit 1), and requests that the Court grant this motion without delay, to uphold the appearance of fairness, impartiality, and public confidence in these judicial proceedings.

Exact text SHA-256 9c9c0a07d3935d1ccbedcf6a4111a9a65bc10ecc2c988656ad0d8a80022041c3

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-15WOhPAK2RuQDNJqWOAA41hxJ4mw8g3Eb:substantive-completion:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-15WOhPAK2RuQDNJqWOAA41hxJ4mw8g3Eb:substantive-completion:033:footnotes-1-3-start

FOOTNOTES
1. Oklahoma Code of Judicial Conduct, Rule 2.11(A) ( “A judge shall disqualify himself or herself in any proceeding in which the judge’s impartiality might reasonably be questioned…”).
2. 20 O.S. § 1401(E) (“The disqualifications provided for in this section shall not exclude the disqualifications at common law.”).
3. Rule 15(a), Rules for District Courts of Oklahoma, 12 O.S. Ch. 2, App. ("Before filing any motion to disqualify a judge, an in camera request shall first be made to the judge to disqualify or to transfer the cause to another judge. If such request is not satisfactorily resolved, not less than ten (10) days before the case is set for trial a motion to disqualify a judge or to transfer a cause to another judge may be filed and a copy

Exact text SHA-256 9cf0d2244eeb86c5209b6dc007711b001926e519b211d12fc4c6ead409ae0206

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-15WOhPAK2RuQDNJqWOAA41hxJ4mw8g3Eb:substantive-completion:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-15WOhPAK2RuQDNJqWOAA41hxJ4mw8g3Eb:substantive-completion:033:footnotes-3-end-5

delivered to the judge.").
4. Id.
5. Rule 15(d), Rules for District Courts (“When an interested party has filed a formal motion for a judge to disqualify or recuse, the judge cannot proceed with the case until the disqualification stands overruled of record following a party's compliance with this rule. Miller Dollarhide, P.C. v. Tal, 2007 OK 58, 163 P.3d 548. “Overruled of record” occurs when the interested party's request to disqualify or recuse has been denied by the judge, the Chief or Presiding Judge, and the appellate court or the time for the interested party to complete Rule 15(a)-(c) has expired.”).

Exact text SHA-256 22db00f2a46095ac32e88067702df8ab8d375131c6c9b7adc9507b131885485d

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-15WOhPAK2RuQDNJqWOAA41hxJ4mw8g3Eb:substantive-completion:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-15WOhPAK2RuQDNJqWOAA41hxJ4mw8g3Eb:substantive-completion:033:legal-standards-a

II. LEGAL STANDARDS FOR DISQUALIFICATION
A. Rule 2.11(A) – Appearance of Impartiality Standard
Oklahoma law mandates that judges recuse themselves in any proceeding where their impartiality might reasonably be questioned. Rule 2.11(A) of the Oklahoma Code of Judicial Conduct states in relevant part:
A judge shall disqualify himself or herself in any proceeding in which the judge’s impartiality might reasonably be questioned , including but not limited to the following circumstances…⁶
This language establishes a clear, objective standard: judicial disqualification does not depend on proof of actual bias, prejudice, or improper conduct, but instead focuses strictly on whether a fully informed, reasonable observer could have legitimate concerns regarding the judge’s neutrality.
As stated in Comment [1] to Rule 2.11:
…Under this Rule, a judge is disqualified whenever the judge's impartiality might reasonably be questioned, regardless of whether any of the specific provisions of paragraphs (A)(1) through (6) apply.⁷
Paragraph (A)’s opening sentence sets an objective appearance standard that stands in addition to the mandatory grounds listed in (A)(1)-(6).

Exact text SHA-256 519bcdd70814f34bc3aa5e9b6d8f55d574028866fc2477d6b003c4c997882239

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-15WOhPAK2RuQDNJqWOAA41hxJ4mw8g3Eb:substantive-completion:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-15WOhPAK2RuQDNJqWOAA41hxJ4mw8g3Eb:substantive-completion:033:legal-standards-a-b

The Oklahoma Supreme Court has affirmed that this standard is not limited to ethics rules but is grounded in due process. In Pierce v. Pierce, 2001 OK 97, ¶ 18, the Court emphasized:
The reach of due process jurisprudence requires not only a fair tribunal, but also the appearance of a fair tribunal… ‘Justice must satisfy the appearance of justice,’ and this stringent rule may sometimes bar trial by judges who have no actual bias and who would do their very best to weigh the scales of justice equally between contending parties.⁸
— Id. ¶ 18 (quoting In re Murchison, Marshall v. Jerrico, Offutt v. United States)
This principle compels disqualification not just when impropriety is shown, but when the integrity of the forum itself would reasonably be called into doubt by an informed member of the public.
B. Statutory and Common Law Grounds – 20 O.S. § 1401(E)
Oklahoma statutory law recognizes that disqualification may arise not only from enumerated conflicts, but also from broader principles of fairness rooted in common law. Title 20, Section 1401(E) provides:
The disqualifications provided for in this section shall not exclude the disqualifications at common law.⁹
This clause preserves the judiciary’s duty to avoid even the appearance of bias, and affirms that disqualification is warranted when a judge’s impartiality might reasonably be questioned—whether or not a statutory per se conflict is present.
The same principle underlies Rule 2.11(A) and the Oklahoma Supreme Court’s due process jurisprudence. The focus is not limited to actual impropriety, but includes circumstances where a

Exact text SHA-256 a2ed24c1b9b3185dae55e28813bee5345bfe23b6344399a2dc6eb7886e694e34

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-15WOhPAK2RuQDNJqWOAA41hxJ4mw8g3Eb:substantive-completion:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-15WOhPAK2RuQDNJqWOAA41hxJ4mw8g3Eb:substantive-completion:033:legal-standards-b-end-c

reasonable observer could perceive partiality. Common-law disqualification thus remains a valid and independent basis for recusal.
.C. Rule 15 – Procedural Compliance and the Mandatory Judicial Stay
Pursuant to Rule 15(a) of the Rules for District Courts,¹⁰ Defendant submitted a sealed in camera request for recusal on May 3, 2025, delivered to the courthouse on May 8, 2025. No ruling has appeared on the docket. Under the rule, this constitutes an unsatisfactory resolution.¹¹
Rule 15(a) permits a formal motion to disqualify where filed at least ten days before trial. As no trial date is currently set, this motion is timely.
Upon filing, Rule 15(d) mandates a full stay:
The judge cannot proceed with the case until the disqualification stands overruled of record following a party's compliance with this rule….
— Rule 15(d), citing Miller Dollarhide, P.C. v. Tal, 2007 OK 58.¹²
The Oklahoma Supreme Court has affirmed that continued participation under these conditions is a due process violation:
A trial judge’s continued participation while motions to disqualify are pending results in a deprivation of due process.
— Id., ¶ 1.¹³
Every litigant is entitled to nothing less than the cold neutrality of an impartial judge… The quest for recusal may not be ignored, nor is a judge free to proceed with the case until the challenge stands overruled of record following a judicial inquiry into the issue. . . .
— Id., ¶ 9.¹⁴
Because the disqualification motion has not been resolved of record through the procedure outlined in Rule 15, the Court is presently barred from taking further action in this case.

Exact text SHA-256 e37be11626e8770c8a45ff70bf49de8a5c8839db0bd63f448b54c784f85f42bc

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-15WOhPAK2RuQDNJqWOAA41hxJ4mw8g3Eb:substantive-completion:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-15WOhPAK2RuQDNJqWOAA41hxJ4mw8g3Eb:substantive-completion:033:footnotes-6-14

FOOTNOTES
6. Code of Jud. Conduct, Rule 2.11, 5 O. S. A. Ch. 1, App. 4, OK ST CJC Rule 2.11
7. See Oklahoma Code of Judicial Conduct, Rule 2.11 cmt. [1] (T. 5, Ch. 1, App. 4); adopted by order of the Oklahoma Supreme Court, April 15, 2011.
8. Pierce v. Pierce, 2001 OK 97, ¶ 18, 39 P.3d 791 (Okla. 2001) (citing In re Murchison, 349 U.S. 133, 136 (1955); Marshall v. Jerrico, Inc., 446 U.S. 238, 242–43 (1980); Offutt v. United States, 348 U.S. 11, 14 (1954)).
9. 20 O.S. § 1401(E).
10. Rule 15(a), Rules for District Courts of Oklahoma, 12 O.S. Ch. 2, App.
11. Id.
12. Rule 15(d), Rules for District Courts (incorporating Miller Dollarhide, P.C. v. Tal, 2007 OK 58, 163 P.3d 548).
13. Miller Dollarhide, P.C. v. Tal, 2007 OK 58, ¶ 1, 163 P.3d 548 (Okla. 2007).
14. Id., ¶ 9.

Exact text SHA-256 22d00b3922c1d9529f83d0c051a56243fe7d10cd37ef2d4de6817f2f494aaada

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-15WOhPAK2RuQDNJqWOAA41hxJ4mw8g3Eb:substantive-completion:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-15WOhPAK2RuQDNJqWOAA41hxJ4mw8g3Eb:substantive-completion:033:factual-summary-1-3

III. FACTUAL SUMMARY (CHRONOLOGICAL NARRATIVE)
The following chronology is set forth without argument or commentary and reflects undisputed factual events supported by Defendant’s affidavit, court records, and publicly accessible minute entries on the Oklahoma State Courts Network (OSCN):
1. On July 5, 2024, Defendant was arrested in Washington County, Oklahoma. That same day, the State filed a criminal Information under 63 O.S. § 2-402, alleging unlawful possession of a controlled dangerous substance.
2. Defendant posted bond and was released on July 6, 2024.
3. On July 8, 2024, Defendant appeared before the Court for arraignment, where a plea of Not Guilty was entered on his behalf.

Exact text SHA-256 9fa1bf351debc7efbf7c2147358bba98e738ad156450b6965e20b49816eb3a2e

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-15WOhPAK2RuQDNJqWOAA41hxJ4mw8g3Eb:substantive-completion:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-15WOhPAK2RuQDNJqWOAA41hxJ4mw8g3Eb:substantive-completion:033:factual-summary-4-10

4. On July 11, 2024, Defendant filed a Pro Se Motion for Discovery, explicitly requesting production of all evidence, including laboratory reports.
5. On July 31, 2024, the Court acknowledged Defendant’s discovery motion, as reflected in a minute entry, but no ruling was entered, and no discovery was produced at that time.
6. On September 4, 2024, Defendant appeared in court for the first time represented by appointed counsel. Counsel formally requested on the record the production of the laboratory report and related discovery materials.
7. On September 5, 2024, the Oklahoma State Bureau of Investigation (OSBI) issued a Criminalistics Examination Report related to the substance seized at Defendant’s arrest. The report prominently displayed “Date Reported: September 5, 2024” and was clearly marked as copied (“CC”) to the Washington County District Attorney’s Office.
8. At a hearing held on October 9, 2024, Defendant’s counsel again advised the Court on record that the OSBI report had not yet been disclosed by the State. At this same hearing, William Drake, currently District Attorney and former colleague of the presiding judge, personally appeared on behalf of the State.
9. On December 19, 2024, immediately prior to a scheduled jury trial sounding docket, Defendant was shown the OSBI report for the first time by his counsel in person. On that date, the Court set a motion cutoff date of January 10, 2025, and a jury trial date of January 27, 2025.
10. On December 31, 2024, the State filed a First Amended Information, altering the alleged substance involved. The amended charge was filed without leave of court and without an affidavit of good cause, contrary to 22 O.S. § 304.

Exact text SHA-256 6805d461a9b6309ad78a9e536fdd15859fae3868df3b134abe235f29ea8d3d90

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-15WOhPAK2RuQDNJqWOAA41hxJ4mw8g3Eb:substantive-completion:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-15WOhPAK2RuQDNJqWOAA41hxJ4mw8g3Eb:substantive-completion:033:factual-summary-11-14

11. On January 10, 2025, Defendant personally obtained a paper copy of the amended charge at the Washington County Clerk’s Office. A hearing was held later that day at which District Attorney William Drake again appeared. The previously scheduled jury trial was vacated at this hearing.
12. On April 9, 2025, the Court granted Defendant’s Motion to Proceed Pro Se, during which Defendant explicitly requested that former counsel be ordered to provide Defendant’s complete case file, which had not been provided.
13. On May 3, 2025, Defendant mailed a sealed, in-camera request to Judge Jared Sigler, pursuant to Rule 15(a), requesting voluntary recusal based on the circumstances described herein. USPS tracking confirms delivery of this request to the Washington County Courthouse on May 8, 2025.
14. As of May 13, 2025, no docket entry reflected a response or ruling to Defendant’s in-camera request. This formal motion for judicial disqualification was then prepared and filed accordingly.
This factual summary reflects the record as it currently exists, without legal argument or inference, provided for the Court’s clear reference as it evaluates the present motion under the applicable legal standards.¹⁵ ¹⁶

Exact text SHA-256 0bfe8e90b7a9f0c5de3620c51bc5ed31cfdf9efeb0d29c0f8e5b7d448f3670ec

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-15WOhPAK2RuQDNJqWOAA41hxJ4mw8g3Eb:substantive-completion:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-15WOhPAK2RuQDNJqWOAA41hxJ4mw8g3Eb:substantive-completion:033:footnotes-15-16

FOOTNOTES
15. See Affidavit of Flynn Robert Martin (filed in support of this motion), ¶¶ 2–18.
16. See also Exhibit 1 – Procedural Timeline (compiled from OSCN minute entries, 07/05/24 through 05/12/25).

Exact text SHA-256 6c2c572db6bb36ddf4b03be62cfcb73e67680f6df9d9723358ef254a242ef2f6

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-15WOhPAK2RuQDNJqWOAA41hxJ4mw8g3Eb:substantive-completion:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-15WOhPAK2RuQDNJqWOAA41hxJ4mw8g3Eb:substantive-completion:033:application-heading

IV. APPLICATION OF LAW TO FACTS — COMBINED APPEARANCE ANALYSIS

Exact text SHA-256 0173e6938369db0b3a366ff14525a3bc96f1b8022eb9d5065f85323baabc8300

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-15WOhPAK2RuQDNJqWOAA41hxJ4mw8g3Eb:substantive-completion:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-15WOhPAK2RuQDNJqWOAA41hxJ4mw8g3Eb:substantive-completion:033:application-a-start

A. One-Hundred-Day Gap Followed by Post-Plea Amendment Filed Without Statutory Compliance
On September 5, 2024, the Oklahoma State Bureau of Investigation issued a Criminalistics Examination Report in connection with the seized substance at issue in this case. The report is clearly marked “Date Reported: September 5, 2024” and bears a “CC: Washington County DA Office” notation, indicating that the District Attorney’s Office received it contemporaneously with its issuance.¹⁷
More than one hundred days later, on December 31, 2024, the State filed a First Amended Information materially altering the substance named in the charge. By that time, the Defendant had already entered a plea, and the Court had set both a jury trial date and a motion cutoff. The record reflects that this post-plea amendment was filed without a court order and without any affidavit showing good cause.¹⁸
Under 22 O.S. § 304,
an information may be amended in matters of substance or form after plea on order of the court where the same can be done without material prejudice to the right of the defendant; but no amendment shall cause any delay of the trial, unless for good cause shown by affidavit.¹⁹
In this case, the amendment followed a substantial procedural gap during which the State, despite being in possession of the OSBI report, took no recorded action to amend or disclose.
At the next hearing on January 10, 2025, the Court vacated the previously scheduled jury trial but made no inquiry into the statutory irregularity surrounding the amendment. Nor did the Court address the significance of the delay between the OSBI report’s issuance and the amendment’s timing.²⁰

Exact text SHA-256 80ae568b76942fe6f358fee346fdfac6d1ccdef97194053cc59d17b92f88c22b

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-15WOhPAK2RuQDNJqWOAA41hxJ4mw8g3Eb:substantive-completion:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-15WOhPAK2RuQDNJqWOAA41hxJ4mw8g3Eb:substantive-completion:033:application-a-end-b-start

To a reasonable observer, this sequence creates the appearance that the State was permitted to amend the charge after plea without meeting the statutory requirements applicable to such an amendment, and that the Court implicitly endorsed this irregularity by taking no corrective action. The fact that the amendment followed more than three months of inaction despite the existence of material forensic evidence further compounds the impression of prosecutorial leniency.
This pattern, when left unaddressed, creates the appearance that the judiciary tolerated an improper post-plea amendment without statutory compliance, reinforcing the concern that the State received procedural leniency.
B. Personal Appearances by District Attorney William Drake Amplify the Appearance of Impropriety
William Drake, the current elected District Attorney for Washington County, served for years in the same office as the Honorable Judge Jared Sigler. From 2011 through 2017, Judge Sigler held the role of First Assistant District Attorney while Mr. Drake served concurrently as an Assistant District Attorney. The two worked under the same prosecutorial leadership and served in overlapping roles during that time.²¹
In this case, Mr. Drake personally appeared on behalf of the State at two hearings of decisive procedural significance.
The first hearing took place on October 9, 2024—thirty-four days after the OSBI issued its forensic report, which was marked as copied to the District Attorney.¹⁷ By that date, the State had made no disclosure, and defense counsel stated on the record that the report still had not

Exact text SHA-256 a38ebfa35e86e1d786a0afb7aed7bd86bbcf3800ec79f1e00fd238ec0222af47

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-15WOhPAK2RuQDNJqWOAA41hxJ4mw8g3Eb:substantive-completion:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-15WOhPAK2RuQDNJqWOAA41hxJ4mw8g3Eb:substantive-completion:033:application-b-end

been received.²² The State, represented by Mr. Drake, did not acknowledge possession of the report or offer any explanation for the delay. The Court likewise made no inquiry into the report’s status or the State’s duty of production, despite the passage of more than a month since issuance.
The second hearing occurred on January 10, 2025, following the State’s December 31, 2024 filing of a First Amended Information—submitted without a court order and without an affidavit of good cause as required by 22 O.S. § 304.¹⁹ At that hearing, Mr. Drake again appeared for the State.²³ The Court vacated the previously set jury trial date but made no reference to the statutory requirements governing post-plea amendments, nor to the substantial delay between the OSBI report and the amendment’s filing. The amended charge followed more than one hundred days of inaction despite the State’s possession of material forensic evidence.
Mr. Drake’s personal appearances at these two hearings—one marking the point where the State failed to disclose a key forensic report, and the other marking the Court’s acceptance of an improper post-plea amendment—occurred at the precise moments when basic procedural protections were most in question. In both instances, the record reflects tolerance of State inaction or irregularity, and in both instances, the presiding judge’s former colleague was the face of the prosecution.
A fully informed and reasonable observer, aware of this history, the significance of the two hearings, and the roles played by both the Court and the District Attorney, could fairly and objectively question whether the proceedings were conducted with the strict neutrality required of the judiciary.²⁴
C. Reasonable-Observer Test Satisfied

Exact text SHA-256 a05b7eb915e011e02481a1d3bf4a7c6723a39c23352e064407d1638f0af5171b

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-15WOhPAK2RuQDNJqWOAA41hxJ4mw8g3Eb:substantive-completion:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-15WOhPAK2RuQDNJqWOAA41hxJ4mw8g3Eb:substantive-completion:033:application-c-start

The legal standard governing judicial disqualification in Oklahoma does not turn on whether a judge acted with improper intent or demonstrated actual bias. Under Rule 2.11(A) of the Oklahoma Code of Judicial Conduct, the question is whether a reasonable person, fully informed of the relevant facts, could reasonably question the judge’s impartiality.²⁵ This objective test focuses on appearances rather than motivations, and its purpose is to preserve public trust in the neutrality of the judicial process.²⁶
Here, that standard is clearly satisfied.
A reasonable, fully informed observer would see that the State had possession of a laboratory report as early as September 5, 2024.¹⁷ More than one hundred days passed without that report being disclosed to the defense. Shortly after disclosure finally occurred, the State filed an amended charge—post-plea and without compliance with the procedures outlined in 22 O.S. § 304.¹⁹ The Court did not inquire into this sequence of events, and instead vacated the trial date without addressing the irregularities.²⁷
At both critical procedural junctures—October 9, 2024, when the undisclosed OSBI report was discussed, and January 10, 2025, when the improper amendment was allowed to stand—District Attorney William Drake appeared personally on behalf of the State.²³ Mr. Drake previously served for six years in the same office and under the same leadership as the presiding judge.²¹ His presence at these decisive hearings, paired with the Court’s tolerance of statutory noncompliance and prolonged procedural silence, compounds the perception that the State received leniency not afforded to the defense.
These circumstances, viewed collectively, would lead a reasonable member of the public to question whether the judge’s prior professional relationship with the District Attorney

Exact text SHA-256 199a8d136d35123982231f7bd7eace3d9ff77930a8320ea8172e4d047a0c43d0

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-15WOhPAK2RuQDNJqWOAA41hxJ4mw8g3Eb:substantive-completion:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-15WOhPAK2RuQDNJqWOAA41hxJ4mw8g3Eb:substantive-completion:033:application-c-end

influenced—or appeared to influence—the Court’s willingness to scrutinize the State’s procedural conduct. Under Rule 2.11(A) and 20 O.S. § 1401(E),²⁸ such an appearance of partiality is sufficient to require disqualification.

Exact text SHA-256 143757aefa592063e22ba340f81fa61c4e079b71969447789f72ac359f215ae5

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-15WOhPAK2RuQDNJqWOAA41hxJ4mw8g3Eb:substantive-completion:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-15WOhPAK2RuQDNJqWOAA41hxJ4mw8g3Eb:substantive-completion:033:footnotes-17-28

FOOTNOTES
17. OSBI Criminalistics Examination Report, dated September 5, 2024, marked “CC: Washington County DA Office.”
18. See Affidavit of Flynn Robert Martin, ¶¶ 9–11; First Amended Information filed December 31, 2024 (not uploaded to OSCN).
19. 22 O.S. § 304
20. See Minute Entry, January 10, 2025 (hearing vacated trial but did not address amendment procedure).
21. See Affidavit of Flynn Robert Martin, ¶ 19; employment history of Judge Sigler and William Drake, publicly reported and confirmed by prosecutorial office structure (2011–2017).
22. See Minute Entry dated October 9, 2024; on-record statement by defense counsel regarding nondisclosure of OSBI report.
23. See Minute Entry dated January 10, 2025 (noting appearance of William Drake).
24. See Oklahoma Code of Judicial Conduct, Rule 2.11(A); see also Pierce v. Pierce, 2001 OK 97, ¶ 18 (due process requires both actual and apparent fairness).
25. Oklahoma Code of Judicial Conduct, Rule 2.11(A).
26. See Canon 1, Preamble to the Oklahoma Code of Judicial Conduct (“Public confidence … appearance of impropriety.”).
27. See Minute Entry dated January 10, 2025.
28. See Pierce v. Pierce, 2001 OK 97, ¶ 18 (disqualification warranted when impartiality “might reasonably be questioned”); see also 20 O.S. § 1401(E) (preserving common-law appearance-based grounds for recusal).

Exact text SHA-256 d08af2a813e80caebab5e327a64e1ce8f766a36a4c0ae5426f76565af64267af

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-15WOhPAK2RuQDNJqWOAA41hxJ4mw8g3Eb:substantive-completion:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-15WOhPAK2RuQDNJqWOAA41hxJ4mw8g3Eb:substantive-completion:033:procedural-relief-request-start

V. PROCEDURAL RELIEF AND DISQUALIFICATION REQUEST
In light of the foregoing, Defendant respectfully requests that the Honorable Judge Jared Sigler recuse himself from further involvement in this matter and that the case be reassigned to a different judge in accordance with the applicable procedures.
This motion has been filed pursuant to Rule 15 of the Rules for District Courts, following strict compliance with the required in-camera request under Rule 15(a), which was delivered to chambers on May 8, 2025.²⁹ No trial date has been set, and the motion is therefore timely under Rule 15(a), which permits disqualification motions to be filed “not less than ten (10) days before the case is set for trial.”³⁰

Exact text SHA-256 4adc7b02c3b4e0ac646dc01e0aa5f781e2f071db0eac78933ea3b4d45acf1105

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-15WOhPAK2RuQDNJqWOAA41hxJ4mw8g3Eb:substantive-completion:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-15WOhPAK2RuQDNJqWOAA41hxJ4mw8g3Eb:substantive-completion:033:procedural-relief-request-end

Under Rule 15(d), once a motion to disqualify has been filed, the judge is prohibited from taking further action in the case until disqualification is “overruled of record.”³¹ The Oklahoma Supreme Court has made clear that this requirement is not merely administrative—it is grounded in due process. In Miller Dollarhide, P.C. v. Tal, the Court held:
A trial judge’s continued participation while motions to disqualify are pending results in a deprivation of due process.³²
The quest for recusal may not be ignored, nor is a judge free to proceed with the case until the challenge stands overruled of record following a judicial inquiry into the issue.³³
If the Court declines to voluntarily recuse, Defendant will exercise his right to re-present this motion to the Chief Judge of the District within five (5) days pursuant to Rule 15(b), and reserves all rights under the Oklahoma Constitution, statutory law, and relevant precedent to seek further review.
This request is made respectfully and without accusation of actual bias or misconduct. Defendant merely seeks to preserve the appearance of fairness, the integrity of the proceedings, and the public’s confidence in judicial impartiality, consistent with Rule 2.11(A) of the Oklahoma Code of Judicial Conduct and 20 O.S. § 1401(E).³⁴

Exact text SHA-256 e19ef559b874a79803979832414ddb02ae1e1662393cce49acedb14fbdde6507

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-15WOhPAK2RuQDNJqWOAA41hxJ4mw8g3Eb:substantive-completion:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-15WOhPAK2RuQDNJqWOAA41hxJ4mw8g3Eb:substantive-completion:033:footnotes-29-34

FOOTNOTES
29. See Affidavit of Flynn Robert Martin, ¶ 15; USPS delivery confirmation dated May 8, 2025.
30. Rules for District Courts of Oklahoma, Rule 15(a), 12 O.S. Ch. 2, App.
31. Rules for District Courts of Oklahoma, Rule 15(d), 12 O.S. Ch. 2, App. (“The judge cannot proceed with the case until the disqualification stands overruled of record…”); see also Miller Dollarhide, P.C. v. Tal, 2007 OK 58, 163 P.3d 548.
32. Miller Dollarhide, 2007 OK 58, ¶ 1.
33. Id., ¶ 9.
34. Oklahoma Code of Judicial Conduct, Rule 2.11(A); 20 O.S. § 1401(E).

Exact text SHA-256 740f6938715f1a6eea8dcdb43bfd812b7c8de664b49e8150a3a71e62dd105258

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-15WOhPAK2RuQDNJqWOAA41hxJ4mw8g3Eb:substantive-completion:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-15WOhPAK2RuQDNJqWOAA41hxJ4mw8g3Eb:substantive-completion:033:prayer

VI. PRAYER FOR RELIEF
WHEREFORE, premises considered, Defendant respectfully prays that the Honorable Judge Jared Sigler enter an order of recusal in the above-captioned matter and that this case be promptly reassigned to another judge in accordance with the procedures set forth in Rule 15 of the Rules for District Courts.
Defendant further requests that, consistent with Rule 15(d), no further judicial action be taken in this case unless and until the disqualification motion is resolved on the record. In the event this motion is denied, Defendant gives notice of intent to re-present the matter to the Chief Judge within the time prescribed by Rule 15(b).
Defendant makes this request without personal animus or allegation of misconduct and solely to preserve the appearance of impartiality and public trust in the administration of justice.

Exact text SHA-256 07e2e3cb30e32e3d496b533b5fa662901d0e033bdf47107eeaf04e65aafe90b1

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-15WOhPAK2RuQDNJqWOAA41hxJ4mw8g3Eb:substantive-completion:033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-15WOhPAK2RuQDNJqWOAA41hxJ4mw8g3Eb:substantive-completion:033:service-certificate

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I hereby certify that on this 13th day of May, 2025, I caused the foregoing Motion to Disqualify to be delivered via overnight private courier to the Clerk of the District Court of Washington County, Oklahoma, for filing and distribution.
Defendant respectfully requests that the Clerk:
1. File-stamp the original and retain it for the official court record;
2. Place a file-stamped copy in the box of the Honorable Judge Jared Sigler; and
3. Place a file-stamped copy in the box of the Washington County District Attorney’s Office.
This filing is submitted in compliance with the Rules for District Courts of Oklahoma and all applicable local procedures.
Respectfully submitted,

Exact text SHA-256 6660919c5978ba847e45cdefe9b78d53f8f6d6fa8b0823e7f29d2ad037ae9ecb