The Oklahoma Fugitive

Record archive

BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF PETITION FOR WRIT OF PROHIBITION (FROM PRO-SE DEFENDANT) (COPY PUT IN JUDGE & DA'S BOX)

Source-owning proceeding: PR-2025-480 · Existing document identity: 1061871449

Existing contextual aliases: D36. Aliases do not establish provenance.

View original PDF Download unchanged original

Unmodified, unredacted retained PDF; 17 physical page/image position(s), 989976 bytes.

Original and shipped SHA-256 137181ea5169f80daa52582d1d97c42a4ec145bae2844f87476a1a8db36408ed

Retained-source provenance

Separate docket appearances

A docket entry is distinct from the source-owned original document. Cross-proceeding entries link to this single original; no second authoritative copy is created.

CM-2024-00301 · ROW-064 · entry date as printed: 06/23/2025

PR-2025-480 · PR034-ROW-005 · entry date as printed: 06-17-2025

Existing text coverage and recorded date roles

Only the listed existing permitted passages are searchable. Original images/PDFs and existing omissions remain unchanged; no OCR or inferred complete text. Representations remain separate and passages retain their existing source order/locators. No inferred continuous page transcription.

Inherited transcription/review notes describe prior source review, including any wording such as “this session”; no new transcription was performed for this export.

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033

Selected existing passages

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p1:b1

ORIGINAL

Exact text SHA-256 962f85a27854336f3286ad54b49321f62525043b5f3508b2ecc887fdd6e7550e

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p1:b2

FILED
IN COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS
STATE OF OKLAHOMA
JUN 17 2025

Exact text SHA-256 17ced791e128de54eba5a5dc72b2a7e99bec3c398a4a10d3f4fb93e825e5db00

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p1:b3

P R 2025 480

Exact text SHA-256 a6f35563d62f020e41068d6d74ce36d215d0af1f37d2621d65778a786d70af56

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p1:b4

IN THE COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS
STATE OF OKLAHOMA
FLYNN ROBERT MARTIN,
Petitioner,
v.
HON. JARED SIGLER,
Special Judge,
Washington County District Court,
Respondent.
Case No. (OCCA)
District Court No. CM-2024-00301

Exact text SHA-256 30ba17e8b6ba1402428838beec7a99a0a1d9ae88ecf89a51fbacc757693729bd

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p1:b5

BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF PETITION FOR WRIT OF PROHIBITION

Exact text SHA-256 33cd25025dff7b6ad8c2655339c4f2680f8282dc1976f37944ce1283ea399234

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p1:b6

Submitted by:
Flynn Robert Martin, Petitioner pro se

Exact text SHA-256 6a8a80a6c330808c2d57dcbd7ccf2c3844915934bcf8687028769d6e8cd88d6e

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p2:b1

TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page

Exact text SHA-256 1df79dc11c608dde99279583421efa6929bfefd4112578af3fde0c8817fbd1a8

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p2:b2

TABLE OF AUTHORITIES

Exact text SHA-256 abffb760ad2850995db5f243c5989d44b90deaa2a0baa5ed599cfdf8685aabd4

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p2:b3

Subject-Matter and Nature of Relief 1
I. Statement of the Case 1
II. Statement of Facts 2
PROPOSITION I 5
PROPOSITION II 7
PROPOSITION III 9
A. Liberty Interest Under Immediate Threat 9
B. Procedural Deadlock 10
C. Conclusion On Irreparable Harm 12
CONCLUSION AND PRAYER FOR RELIEF 13
Certificate of Service 14

Exact text SHA-256 f02cdeb620ee48ada38b1af2a94a8c0da9b4dea891930289545edfedd00b8c15

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p3:b1

TABLE OF AUTHORITIES
Page

Exact text SHA-256 7cece4201f599162d025361668c89cbbc1ab480fed37e7bbc7f7054d21470085

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p3:b2

Cases
Clark v. Bd. of Educ. of Indep. Sch. Dist. No. 89, 2001 OK 56 6, 8, 11
Evans v. Willis, 22 Okla. 310, 97 P. 1047 (1908) 10
Maynard v. Layden, 1992 OK CR 31 5, 7, 9
Miller Dollarhide, P.C. v. Tal, 2007 OK 58 5, 6, 7, 10, 11
State ex rel. Wise v. Clanton, 1977 OK CR 45 9, 10

Exact text SHA-256 5e8b1377741bb7f1f3210495476ddfd59f6cc29b935e4ca6694f1027957c23ce

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p3:b3

Statutes & Rules
63 O.S. § 2-402 1, 2
Rule 15(a), Rules for District Courts of Oklahoma 2, 10
Rule 15(b), Rules for District Courts of Oklahoma 8, 11
Rule 15(d), Rules for District Courts of Oklahoma 1, 2, 5, 7, 9

Exact text SHA-256 79f036ff0efc223a78eb2505b353a99e2ceef619a0a8d14030e9239f7cffce71

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p4:b1

Subject-Matter and Nature of Relief

Exact text SHA-256 4b8e80f05f80c06e4d2d8c570f1682017d7d4295c4fe091774268bbe5174ddaa

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p4:b2

This petition arises from Washington County District Court Case No. CM-2024-00301, a pending misdemeanor charge of Possession of a Schedule II Controlled Dangerous Substance, 63 O.S. § 2-402. On May 14, 2025, Petitioner filed a verified Rule 15 motion to disqualify the presiding judge; no ruling has been entered. Under Rule 15(d), that filing automatically stayed further judicial action.¹ Nevertheless, Respondent has continued to preside and has set another hearing for June 24, 2025.

Exact text SHA-256 7f667e2fb83402eee48e81a3eb964bd74bcd906c127596ff8c11d7f6871dfd18

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p4:b3

Petitioner therefore seeks a writ of prohibition directing Respondent to refrain from any further exercise of jurisdiction—including the June 24, 2025 setting—until the disqualification motion is heard and “stands overruled of record” within the meaning of Rule 15(d). Immediate intervention is required to enforce the mandatory stay and protect Petitioner’s constitutional right to an impartial tribunal. Petitioner does not seek delay for its own sake; he seeks only to ensure that proceedings occur before a duly qualified judge.

Exact text SHA-256 a8b670a7d6668d0e947564a62a07e410c62c044146b115761ae3f0f0f35bdd7c

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p4:b4

I. Statement of the Case

Exact text SHA-256 faaeb9799eb98d40e4cdf750e299db53d8151338ca6d5661ecb1475f42b08e57

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p4:b5

Washington County District Court Case No. CM-2024-00301 commenced on July 5, 2024, when the State filed an Information charging Petitioner with misdemeanor possession of a Schedule II

Exact text SHA-256 6bf293f408eb07b9db31bfbc2f8e1c252eee5b5e784e7127c0e4206966f3ddf9

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p4:b6

¹ “When an interested party has filed a formal motion for a judge to disqualify or recuse, the judge cannot proceed with the case until the disqualification stands overruled of record following a party’s compliance with this rule.” Miller Dollarhide, P.C. v. Tal, 2007 OK 58, 163 P.3d 548.
“Overruled of record” occurs when the interested party’s request to disqualify or recuse has been denied by the judge, the Chief or Presiding Judge, and the appellate court or the time for the interested party to complete Rule 15(a)-(c) has expired. Nothing in this rule shall prevent another judge from proceeding forward with the case, pending resolution of the requested disqualification or recusal of the subject judge.
— Rule 15(d), Rules for District Courts of Oklahoma, 12 O.S. ch. 2, app. (eff. Nov. 18, 2024)

Exact text SHA-256 521dace78020afbcd3a054540397247b17840a6ce25e32230d529392f4ca292f

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p5:b1

controlled dangerous substance, 63 O.S. § 2-402. (O.R. 5.) Petitioner was arrested, released on a $1,000 bond, and entered a plea of not guilty on July 8, 2024. (O.R. 6-8.)

Exact text SHA-256 348e1c744c403797b8cf109288dbd037e3c5df899d8fa54276e314f9e8224dcd

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p5:b2

After a series of defense filings—including a Motion for Appointment of Public Defender, a Motion for Discovery, and a Motion to Dismiss (O.R. 9-13, 14-16, 25-34)—the court on April 9, 2025, granted Petitioner’s request to proceed pro se. (O.R. 39-41.) On May 14, 2025, Petitioner filed a verified motion to disqualify the presiding judge; under Rule 15(d) of the Rules for District Courts, that filing stayed further proceedings until overruled of record. (O.R. 56-71; see also docket entries O.R. 1-4.)

Exact text SHA-256 4130fa99720ad8c1cc4c7ae0ee2ed9a47e9333c2e3f86787ba0cb7ac2ee7f0ae

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p5:b3

Nonetheless, the court convened further settings on May 15, May 28, and May 29, 2025. (O.R. 4.) Petitioner was absent from each. The May 15 and May 29 proceedings were stenographically recorded; the May 28 setting was not. During the May 29 hearing, the State requested issuance of a bench warrant, bond forfeiture, and denial of the disqualification motion. No ruling issued on those requests. (O.R. 4.)

Exact text SHA-256 ba61a805b05f1fb35c1482e385946cf442409c1592584d8e5a449b39d82063b5

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p5:b4

The disqualification motion and related filings remain pending, and the district court has set the next appearance for June 24, 2025. (O.R. 1, 4.)

Exact text SHA-256 361b10ba4e488c89ae0f5cf76ca09bacb7a3887a9edf5e9e3ad1c2293eeba768

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p5:b5

Petitioner now seeks a writ of prohibition preventing further exercise of jurisdiction until the Rule 15 motion is resolved of record.

Exact text SHA-256 1421442d94ba1db8e71e70471cd7337aa93f0d5d265880914b8489491c420329

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p5:b6

II. Statement of Facts

Exact text SHA-256 02dc5eacd52ae0460eff752b042004550ddb0b9f58dc298ff831f46d13abde75

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p5:b7

Petitioner was charged in July 2024 with misdemeanor possession of a controlled dangerous substance under 63 O.S. § 2-402. (O.R. 5.) He was released the following day on a $1,000

Exact text SHA-256 de3397f9e4e0e8d88215185b5f0a6979bb1fbe28c712e3cc6aa5671779271cf1

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p6:b1

appearance bond. (O.R. 6-7.) At arraignment on July 8, 2024, the district court entered a plea of not guilty. (O.R. 8.)

Exact text SHA-256 8604e086b765325a085a974e30b38f5d63bc7fc23d22c08956c951a51334c90d

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p6:b2

On April 9, 2025, the court granted Petitioner’s motion to proceed pro se and permitted appointed counsel to withdraw. (O.R. 39-41.) That same day, Petitioner filed a pro se reply brief in support of his pending motion to dismiss. (O.R. 42-49.) Despite a discovery motion filed on July 11, 2024 (O.R. 14-16), no discovery has been produced by either former counsel or the State, and a related motion to compel discovery filed April 21, 2025 (O.R. 53-55) remains pending.

Exact text SHA-256 142df3fae4a80f8c010db7db5d3b95fcdf2424eb891b9ff99572ed8546ed96ab

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p6:b3

On May 3, 2025, Petitioner mailed a sealed in-camera request for recusal under Rule 15(a).² USPS tracking confirms delivery to the Washington County Court Clerk on May 8, 2025, yet no docket entry was made. (Aff. ¶ 3; Exs. A–B.) Receiving no response, Petitioner filed a verified motion to disqualify Judge Sigler on May 14, 2025, supported by affidavit. (O.R. 56-71, 72-78.) Under Rule 15(d), that filing imposed an automatic stay on further judicial action until the motion is overruled of record.

Exact text SHA-256 1134162fcf723aba69173c93c36e867ff77ea4576e5a572af2723535b1a46ae8

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p6:b4

Nevertheless, on May 15, 2025, Respondent conducted an in-chambers proceeding attended by Assistant District Attorney Veronica Threadgill and court reporter Dee Tanner; the court assessed a reporter fee. (O.R. 1-4.) Petitioner did not attend. During the proceeding, the judge

Exact text SHA-256 b20ad29f033122d9d623c45d55f85df599cc11e6f8a555f2cde33280777f3610

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p6:b5

² “Before filing any motion to disqualify a judge, an in camera request shall first be made to the judge to disqualify or to transfer the cause to another judge. If such request is not satisfactorily resolved, not less than ten (10) days before the case is set for trial a motion to disqualify a judge or to transfer a cause to another judge may be filed and a copy delivered to the judge.”
— Rule 15(a), Rules for District Courts of Oklahoma, 12 O.S. ch. 2, app. (eff. Nov. 18, 2024)

Exact text SHA-256 ebd187101cdf833577e33b8a5e896d2f93e377f5ed479d85511e4b65387005c8

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p7:b1

telephoned Petitioner and left a voicemail stating, “We’re on the record … We’ll give you a new court date of May 28 at 9:00 a.m.” (Aff. Ex. C.)

Exact text SHA-256 02785678bb7e1246f3116367706ee5af030a5654347c39f5536b7e4dd62b9788

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p7:b2

On May 23, 2025, Petitioner filed (1) a Motion Objecting to Further Proceedings During Pendency of Disqualification Motion and Request for Immediate Ruling on the Papers (O.R. 79-87); (2) an Ex Parte Application for Ministerial Relief requesting transcripts (O.R. 88-92); and (3) an updated affidavit of indigency. (O.R. 93-94.) His prior Motion to Assign Court Reporter, filed April 21, 2025, remains pending. (O.R. 50-52.)

Exact text SHA-256 52c567882ff487ef7be2b1282c389b2e0819ea7605c64c4675986cb605b9ede9

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p7:b3

On May 28, 2025, the case was called at 9:00 a.m. without a court reporter present. (Minute entry 05/28/25; O.R. 1-4.) Petitioner did not appear. The matter was passed to 1:30 p.m. and then to the following morning. District Attorney William Drake and bond agent Tami Brinkman were in attendance; Brinkman contacted Petitioner by voicemail, text message, and email, stating that the judge “has been leaving you messages.” (Aff. Exs. D–G.) No transcript exists for any part of the May 28 settings, and no minute entry indicates whether the matter was ever taken up on the record.

Exact text SHA-256 f7e8db3aef98d7a8f9b9c961674c8793bce8f1a4eea70bfbbed8cfd62a595950

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p7:b4

On May 29, 2025, the court reconvened with court reporter Dee Tanner present. (Minute entry 05/29/25; O.R. 1-4.) Assistant District Attorney Threadgill again appeared and requested issuance of a bench warrant, forfeiture of Petitioner’s bond, and denial of the Rule 15 motion. Respondent declined those requests “at this time,” made no ruling on the disqualification motion, and left Petitioner a voicemail setting the next appearance for June 24, 2025, “regarding [the] recusal motion.” (Aff. ¶ 9; Ex. H.) Although the proceeding was transcribed, no transcript has yet been provided.

Exact text SHA-256 c3d091946670ecd832fac8a0f20e3df88d1638dfee499f2ff205c37e661f13e8

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p8:b1

The Rule 15 motion, both discovery motions, the reporter-assignment motion, and the transcript and indigency applications remain undecided. The next scheduled court appearance is June 24, 2025. (O.R. 1-4.)

Exact text SHA-256 b62a258717e7267b1d71a0529a9c71ae515693e58b722ec7ad3b96093ff49452

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p8:b2

PROPOSITION I

Exact text SHA-256 1debf36bfdbddb5208d96708bbf8f7804c82c03ca504e3f07a28f9370c98656c

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p8:b3

Respondent Exercised Judicial Power After the Rule 15(d) Stay, Satisfying Maynard’s First Element

Exact text SHA-256 6fd1922032cdfe0e50b3543d5038dd51d3eb20bc2057050d0f61459571d0df64

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p8:b4

Standard of Review

Exact text SHA-256 6b786c8a8292f9c9be035966cb83ecc54133d011e1f28fdbc0926ac85d06161e

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p8:b5

This Court reviews de novo both jurisdictional questions and alleged violations of Rule 15(d). Maynard v. Layden, 1992 OK CR 31, ¶ 7, 830 P.2d 581, 583; Miller Dollarhide, P.C. v. Tal, 2007 OK 58, ¶ 7, 163 P.3d 548, 551.

Exact text SHA-256 c3da513285b788f0e106b407ff3d608a7415dbc305b3e4c82fb4617921ef1809

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p8:b6

Argument

Exact text SHA-256 481da3a767b1d5439ffb4b0e25b6958533c113d5492236705f4bdd4296b500e4

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p8:b7

Petitioner filed a verified Motion to Disqualify Respondent on May 14, 2025, invoking the automatic stay imposed by Rule 15(d), Rules for District Courts of Oklahoma, 12 O.S. ch. 2, app. (O.R. 56-71, 72-78). Rule 15(d) provides that “the judge cannot proceed with the case until the disqualification stands overruled of record.” Oklahoma appellate precedent enforces that command without exception: when a judge fails to rule on a recusal motion, the party is “deprived of a fundamental right guaranteed by the Due Process Clauses,” and the judge “impermissibly bar[s] [the movant] from all further access to the relief afforded by the Rule 15 procedure.” Clark v. Bd. of Educ. of Indep. Sch. Dist. No. 89, 2001 OK 56, ¶¶ 8, 11, 32 P.3d 851, 854. See also Miller Dollarhide, P.C. v. Tal, 2007 OK 58, ¶ 7, 163 P.3d 548, 551 (continued

Exact text SHA-256 d8ff4b0d07379002129094e73949ca6cd4431932a83ec61159173ec8dac1a47c

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p9:b1

participation while a disqualification motion is pending “results in a deprivation of due process”). As of this filing—more than a month later—no docket entry or written order exists overruling, denying, or transferring Petitioner’s motion. (O.R. 1-4; Aff. ¶ 10.) Respondent’s judicial authority is therefore suspended by operation of law.

Exact text SHA-256 583f6520859fe1711253b70d6cfbdb1ec9d2fd7485c10e68b655f082bd0d264e

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p9:b2

Despite the stay, Respondent repeatedly exercised judicial power. On May 15, 2025, he convened an in-chambers proceeding attended by Assistant District Attorney Veronica Threadgill and court reporter Dee Tanner; the hearing was recorded, and the case was reset. (O.R. 1-4; Aff. ¶ 5; Ex. C.) On May 28, 2025, he presided over two courtroom sessions—both unreported and conducted without Petitioner—resetting the matter twice more. (Minute entry May 28, 2025; O.R. 1-4; Aff. ¶¶ 7-8.) The following day, May 29, 2025, Respondent held another hearing at which the State sought a bench warrant, bond forfeiture, and denial of the Rule 15 motion; although he declined immediate rulings, he scheduled a further appearance for June 24, 2025 “regarding [the] recusal motion.” (Minute entry May 29, 2025; O.R. 1-4; Aff. ¶ 9; Ex. H.)

Exact text SHA-256 ef14088835561ac327ad258030c4c917af98c85ec75445acaf493bc595788dcf

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p9:b3

Respondent’s voicemails remove all doubt that he knew the stay was in force. On May 15 he said, “We’re in chambers ... we’re on the record ... just trying to call you so we could do your recusal request.” (Aff. Ex. C.) On May 29 he told Petitioner that an appearance was needed “so that we can move your case forward.” (Aff. Ex. H.) These recorded admissions demonstrate conscious disregard of the jurisdictional bar.

Exact text SHA-256 e590665d10d113f7458ed6697a3c827b6f7a38e9a2ca65510ea6f8341cfe98f3

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p9:b4

Because Respondent convened hearings, reset the case, and entertained contested motions after the Rule 15(d) stay attached, Petitioner has conclusively established an unauthorized exercise of judicial power. Maynard’s first element is satisfied; the analysis now turns to whether

Exact text SHA-256 ba2e9a2db685f6b4ea173144ce9c40cfbb7ec56228503d136db47f73c1fc91bf

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p10:b1

Respondent’s actions lacked lawful authority (Proposition II) and whether they threaten irreparable injury (Proposition III).

Exact text SHA-256 a0d12e552106d60a00d18afe74bcee900b0608582df79c8eda589b99d950e003

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p10:b2

PROPOSITION II

Exact text SHA-256 04ef0061aae6162a2d8398747a4928864677f8b827eef5016721f3222b7ca2b0

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p10:b3

Respondent’s Post-Stay Acts Were Unauthorized, Satisfying Maynard’s Second Element

Exact text SHA-256 1c31801adbc71be75ac25b7232440bcd37d9d0156748e193756a91f13ca2ed1e

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p10:b4

Standard of Review

Exact text SHA-256 6b786c8a8292f9c9be035966cb83ecc54133d011e1f28fdbc0926ac85d06161e

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p10:b5

Whether a judge exercised power without legal authority is a question of law reviewed de novo. Maynard v. Layden, 1992 OK CR 31, ¶ 7, 830 P.2d 581, 583; Miller Dollarhide, P.C. v. Tal, 2007 OK 58, ¶ 7, 163 P.3d 548, 551.

Exact text SHA-256 23a135b95d37441bfce1a3b9a47fd5f94470a4d46f8c391d4e11a9ae95d01bb3

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p10:b6

Argument

Exact text SHA-256 481da3a767b1d5439ffb4b0e25b6958533c113d5492236705f4bdd4296b500e4

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p10:b7

As shown in Proposition I, Respondent convened three hearings after the automatic stay triggered by Rule 15(d) attached on May 14, 2025. The question now is whether any statute or order authorized those acts. None did.

Exact text SHA-256 3aaccc855837e87e6a41bca91d1b0165e7de59457e1e2aa8387c11454beb7c84

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p10:b8

Rule 15(d) provides that “the judge cannot proceed with the case until the disqualification stands overruled of record.” Oklahoma precedent treats that directive as substantive: a judge’s failure to rule leaves the movant “deprived … of a fundamental right guaranteed by the Due Process Clauses of the Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments” and “impermissibly bar[s] [the movant] from all further access to the relief afforded by the Rule 15 procedure.” Clark v. Bd. of Educ. of Indep. Sch. Dist. No. 89, 2001 OK 56, ¶¶ 8, 11, 32 P.3d 851, 854-55. Miller Dollarhide underscores the point, clarifying that trial courts must “vacate all orders entered while a motion

Exact text SHA-256 07d0003fbfc93b688b80faa1c58c38fd84b1ee7c3ec6926592ffe80a50980d6d

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p11:b1

to recuse is pending and … refrain from further rulings until completion of Rule 15 proceedings.” 2007 OK 58, ¶ 13.

Exact text SHA-256 167a0b8e7d1507d7ae76ba3e07c839c39fca169fd7a23d606e3183c9342f6e69

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p11:b2

Petitioner’s verified Rule 15 motion was filed on May 14, 2025. (O.R. 56-78; Aff. ¶ 4.) Since then, the docket shows no order denying, transferring, or overruling the motion. (O.R. 1-4; Aff. ¶ 10.) Even had Respondent denied it orally, Rule 15(b) required him to enter that denial on the record within five days so that Petitioner could re-present the request to the Chief Judge.³ No such entry exists; the stay therefore remains in force.

Exact text SHA-256 ec5294cf87af3c2d11d93702e316708780b3e42a9c43857bb6b8e6562ce411f4

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p11:b3

Despite this, Respondent (a) held an in-chambers hearing on May 15, 2025 (O.R. 1-4; Aff. ¶ 5; Ex. C); (b) presided over two unreported courtroom sessions on May 28, 2025 (Minute entry May 28, 2025; O.R. 1-4; Aff. ¶¶ 7-8); and (c) conducted a recorded hearing on May 29, 2025 at which the State sought a bench warrant, bond forfeiture, and denial of the disqualification motion—and set a further appearance for June 24, 2025 “regarding [the] recusal motion.” (Minute entry May 29, 2025; O.R. 1-4; Aff. ¶ 9; Ex. H). Each act violated Rule 15(d). Consistent with Miller Dollarhide, ¶ 13, every ruling entered while a disqualification motion pends must be vacated; Clark, ¶ 11, likewise commands abstention until Rule 15 review is complete.

Exact text SHA-256 1995b3fb039fd4853d69bca4590eb8461c77b01f20f52f37ea4ff434101570cb

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p11:b4

Because Respondent’s authority was suspended on May 14, 2025, and nothing revived it, every subsequent judicial act was unauthorized. Petitioner has therefore satisfied Maynard’s second element. The analysis now turns to irreparable injury (Proposition III).

Exact text SHA-256 4cfa70ba893184bc28aeca70de256ef7dd1faeabf690211a66ed2363b49cc53c

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p11:b5

³ “Any interested party who deems himself aggrieved by the refusal of a judge to grant a motion to disqualify or transfer a cause to another judge may re-present his motion to the Chief Judge of the county in which the cause is pending or, if the disqualification of a Chief Judge is sought, to the Presiding Judge of the administrative district by filing in the case within five (5) days from the date of said refusal a written request for re-hearing..
— Rule 15(b), Rules for District Courts of Oklahoma, 12 O.S. ch. 2, app. (eff. Nov. 18, 2024).

Exact text SHA-256 073728b31a55e71046cc5ba987c5a65f05cd333d04a5325634537ad940576ef6

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p12:b1

PROPOSITION III

Exact text SHA-256 2eab5a634b9a3a12f2884879ea1dfae42c5f5af9f64242680a0d1c2a6aa7cfad

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p12:b2

Respondent’s Ultra Vires Acts Have Inflicted Irreparable Harm, Leaving Petitioner Without a Plain, Speedy, or Adequate Remedy, Satisfying Maynard’s Third Element

Exact text SHA-256 1bb449f6e098ff8d881088b5589c0e03207e7e569a3d9b3f6ed5efa805591593

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p12:b3

Standard of Review

Exact text SHA-256 6b786c8a8292f9c9be035966cb83ecc54133d011e1f28fdbc0926ac85d06161e

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p12:b4

Whether an alternative remedy is “plain, speedy, and adequate” is a legal question reviewed de novo. Maynard v. Layden, 1992 OK CR 31, ¶ 7, 830 P.2d 581, 583; State ex rel. Wise v. Clanton, 1977 OK CR 45, ¶ 14, 560 P.2d 588, 591.

Exact text SHA-256 f5f0c03fdfcf2c5c469fdddc9bb28932cdcf7f23168a2d29b53cd7657a4ddfd3

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p12:b5

Argument

Exact text SHA-256 481da3a767b1d5439ffb4b0e25b6958533c113d5492236705f4bdd4296b500e4

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p12:b6

Having shown in Proposition I that Respondent exercised judicial power after the Rule 15(d) stay attached, and in Proposition II that no statute or order authorized those actions, Petitioner now demonstrates that these ultra vires acts inflict irreparable harm and that no plain, speedy, or adequate alternative remedy exists.

Exact text SHA-256 8584a46310be07aa606e07aa0a4bd49d1037c0ff0039ee420d982e07a05970b4

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p12:b7

A. Liberty Interest Under Immediate Threat

Exact text SHA-256 3ac1ca2756fa9234ccbfb04d3d635ce03eaff331628b1ae646554f1bbf900896

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p12:b8

At the May 29, 2025 hearing the State asked for a bench warrant and bond forfeiture solely because Petitioner honored the Rule 15(d) stay. (O.R. 4; minute entry May 29, 2025; Aff. ¶ 9) Respondent deferred ruling “at this time” but reset the matter for June 24, 2025, expressly “regarding [the] recusal motion,” leaving arrest and forfeiture poised to fall at the State’s next request. (O.R. 1, 4; Aff. ¶ 9; Ex. H.)

Exact text SHA-256 dd11ebaf1139742862c635c84ef0b7cfc3962c928cff4340b770eae58519ce4a

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p12:b9

These consequences cannot be undone by later appeal. If Respondent issues the warrant, Petitioner will lose his liberty; if he forfeits bond, the surety is gone. The Oklahoma Court of

Exact text SHA-256 2a0b4c241956d8f3a853b0e526502d98d81aac0e5cc17ee36f84d49dbead8549

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p13:b1

Criminal Appeals has held that where a party faces such “immediate injury or hardship … particularly in criminal cases,” ordinary appellate remedies are “insufficient” and prohibition lies. State ex rel. Wise v. Clanton, 1977 OK CR 45, ¶ 14, 560 P.2d 588, 591 (quoting Evans v. Willis, 22 Okla. 310, 97 P. 1047 (1908)); see also id. ¶ 13 (appeal, “though favorable, is an inadequate and needless procedure” when the alternative is contempt or other coercive sanctions).

Exact text SHA-256 f30113a1516fb4f1f549c7eb9cc5c9c1c43135ce198b47a4efaa6b68bfb6f76f

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p13:b2

Moreover, every ruling Respondent enters while the disqualification motion pends is voidable and must be vacated. See Miller Dollarhide, P.C. v. Tal, 2007 OK 58, ¶ 13, 163 P.3d 548, 552 (directing trial court “to vacate all orders entered while a motion to recuse is pending and to refrain from further rulings until completion of Rule 15 proceedings”). Thus, allowing the June 24 setting—or any warrant or forfeiture—would compound prejudice without any meaningful post-hoc remedy.

Exact text SHA-256 41e61c48863c0c4d55cc87b493c7c9b928cb87b1900fb767eba3e73c828a581d

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p13:b3

Because Respondent’s continued exercise of jurisdiction places Petitioner’s freedom and property in imminent jeopardy, and because “immediate injury or hardship” renders appeal inadequate under Wise, the harm is irreparable and the third element of Maynard is met.

Exact text SHA-256 335f571c4aa64d56493c14802361e00f5e1ffcff0ea7540a7859ef46795d584f

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p13:b4

B. Procedural Deadlock: Respondent’s Non-Ruling Extinguishes Every Statutory and Extraordinary Avenue of Review

Exact text SHA-256 6f90ecc36ed318fd3ee58612e653c59844e19df74c50161291c57ace0beab8cb

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p13:b5

Rule 15 provides a three-step safeguard for securing an impartial tribunal: (1) an in-camera request (Rule 15(a)); (2) a formal motion to disqualify (Rule 15(d)); and (3) if—and only if—that motion is overruled of record, re-presentation to the Chief Judge followed, if still denied, by

Exact text SHA-256 7980a2c6f539dc6edbc6cd95d3477c1b9bcbea82faa165c0f1d0af3cd66f3ae0

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p14:b1

mandamus in this Court (Rule 15(b)). As Footnote 3 shows, a written ruling is the indispensable gateway to both intra-district review and any subsequent extraordinary relief.

Exact text SHA-256 8e2ebb44fd64d498afb45be84ddfae88c3c867aeb3e29a59450581665b100e6e

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p14:b2

Respondent has stalled the process at its threshold. More than a month after Petitioner filed his verified disqualification motion, the docket remains silent—no order denying, granting, or transferring the motion exists. Without an “overruled of record,” Petitioner cannot (1) invoke the Chief Judge’s supervisory review or (2) petition this Court for mandamus, because Rule 15(b) permits mandamus only after an adverse Chief-Judge ruling. The statutory pathway is therefore blocked not by legal defeat but by judicial inaction.

Exact text SHA-256 7592df9b63e0fe4ca211c69588ddc323e83e14d7621bdcf3531109b6770708af

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p14:b3

The Oklahoma Supreme Court has condemned this precise impasse. Clark v. Board of Education holds that a trial judge’s non-ruling “impermissibly barred [the movant] from all further access to the relief afforded by the Rule 15 procedure …” and therefore frustrated the fundamental right to an impartial tribunal. 2001 OK 56, ¶ 11, 32 P.3d 851, 855. Echoing Clark, the Court in Miller Dollarhide directed trial courts “to vacate all orders entered while a motion to recuse is pending and to refrain from further rulings until completion of Rule 15 proceedings.” 2007 OK 58, ¶ 13, 163 P.3d 548, 553.

Exact text SHA-256 38276fa3a89c97cd853f0e9c74a66136904ed08977fd7fa8cc8ecd597ff9dae2

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p14:b4

That is exactly the deadlock here. Respondent’s refusal to rule has (1) frozen the Rule 15 mechanism, (2) foreclosed Chief-Judge review, and (3) rendered mandamus jurisdictionally unavailable. With no interlocutory appeal from judicial silence, Petitioner is trapped in a procedural cul-de-sac fashioned by the very judge whose impartiality is in doubt.

Exact text SHA-256 d0c4b52d856b4a43b1142f5d8a1856d83defc716a362ce13e00885c1fc33ebcc

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p15:b1

This deadlock inflicts irreparable harm by nullifying the sole statutory route for testing bias and leaving Petitioner without any “plain, speedy, and adequate” remedy—an injury Clark and Miller Dollarhide identify as structural and self-executing.

Exact text SHA-256 4431f41455f73d8c996c08725fb06e594943c43bd50d6427a6d48ea1f9f526ab

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p15:b2

C. Conclusion on Irreparable Harm

Exact text SHA-256 1d4bda6fe6c3e343202d5799a7fa6049def946101ec57540dc374ad68aa86486

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p15:b3

The imminent threat of custody and forfeiture (Section A) and the procedural deadlock that forecloses every statutory and extraordinary avenue of review (Section B) each independently destroy any “plain, speedy, and adequate” remedy. Together they present the exact circumstances Maynard deems sufficient for prohibition.

Exact text SHA-256 5c1a176572b8feaa027afda622bf7214da596db8882426c7b617d7035621ebe9

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p16:b1

CONCLUSION AND PRAYER FOR RELIEF

Exact text SHA-256 4f4231218e935f5ecfcae1936a1a007956047904a1079d985adb60363c2b9679

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p16:b2

Petitioner respectfully requests that this Court:

Exact text SHA-256 1798071ca32dd6b37134682289c1a27b9b42bd874b8642eae4edb7f930e261e7

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p16:b3

1. Issue a writ of prohibition commanding Judge Jared Sigler to take no further action in Washington County District Court Case No. CM-2024-00301—including the appearance presently set for June 24, 2025—until Petitioner’s Rule 15 motion to disqualify has been ruled on and “stands overruled of record” under Rule 15(d);

Exact text SHA-256 dfba8ca73f7868bed07df2dabc049dee3fdba58b32edac700f7e244046109c32

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p16:b4

2. Vacate all orders and settings entered while the Rule 15 motion has been pending—specifically the May 15, May 28, May 29, and June 24, 2025 settings, together with any related bench-warrant or bond-forfeiture requests; and

Exact text SHA-256 b6ad3f29b3de835e78ebb3ca4abce4e14fcd21b87053cd66a45c382e6e823793

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p16:b5

3. Grant such other and further relief as justice may require.

Exact text SHA-256 22af5c9198cea5dea6a27b64506e304304b197386ff99e0ff8ae0090995202a1

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p16:b6

Respectfully submitted,

Exact text SHA-256 a0fee356f8359873a75bc863c27fd771648ca8a4ec219caa0325ef2a71e1830b

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p16:b7

Flynn Robert Martin, Petitioner pro se

Exact text SHA-256 bd6dd5c7395cb6b9db739860f9f44e8dfa1b6692e5be1661f2b63f9ec3e33c5f

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p17:b1

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

Exact text SHA-256 3dc19f7617308076d8a0c8c58aee55aacb18e38102b852c1a51925819f27503f

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p17:b2

I certify that on June 17, 2025, I mailed via United States Postal Service Priority Mail true and correct copies of the BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF PETITION FOR WRIT OF PROHIBITION to the following parties at the address listed below:

Exact text SHA-256 0fc189c3d04669211914dfd72fa2d4670e2ef115a5932f4f23226a70c5393629

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p17:b3

Respondent:
Hon. Jared Sigler
Special Judge, Washington County District Court

Exact text SHA-256 00552ec681f8ac240028c2e1cc78548702b61eec103b69b2b0ebebf8dc912fb8

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p17:b4

Real Party in Interest:
William Drake
District Attorney, Washington County

Exact text SHA-256 1d66dd97deab15cce48102bfd7e49f4fce53f5480643e570270c9c132fd07b3a

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p17:b5

Service Address:
Washington County District Attorney’s Office
420 S. Johnstone Avenue
Bartlesville, OK 74003

Exact text SHA-256 7bd7dfdb206933c08df725354c6274b51f110c51262c0754911777dff116e718

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p17:b6

Executed this 17th day of June, 2025.

Exact text SHA-256 00f7cd30ec795fb9d1251253c5170548aee8951147097888b443e4a7d7fad0b1

Current supported transcription · Direct passage link

record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033
record:ASSET-DRIVE-13VahG9_1g3NkoqBxvhAl2XNqwMP9Ncil:readiness033:p17:b7

Flynn Robert Martin

Exact text SHA-256 3d4bedba1cc428b5160999133e12ed2a1ebed0dae112e1a097d9c3418e0427c5